求助 OG12 SC 68

FactOrFiction

8楼，这里的短语是arise with.

小福娃欢欢

8楼，这里的短语是arise with.

-- by 会员 FactOrFiction (2011/4/6 22:01:43)

arise with 又是什么意思。
然后为什么 independently后面用了 of?

谢谢

lottl

完整的应该是：A城市 arose simultaneously with （B城市） but (A城市 arose) independently of B城市，A城市与B城市同时但又独立崛起，或者分成2句话来描述就是：A arose simultaneously with B. But A arose independently of B.

bob9603

完整的应该是：A城市 arose simultaneously with （B城市） but (A城市 arose) independently of B城市，A城市与B城市同时但又独立崛起，或者分成2句话来描述就是：A arose simultaneously with B. But A arose independently of B.

-- by 会员 lottl (2011/7/10 15:45:26)

请问，C中的having been cut 和A中的 that were cut.....and that were arising 为什么是wordy？？？我不懂，请教你一下~

jj449

这个我试着回答一下：
1.根据我看的语法笔记里提到having和being，在GMAT语法里比较不讨喜，选的几率不大。
2. that were cut，“that were”是可以省略的，直接用cut就好。语法笔记里提到，N that is adj，太罗嗦，尽量变成adj N。

完整的应该是：A城市 arose simultaneously with （B城市） but (A城市 arose) independently of B城市，A城市与B城市同时但又独立崛起，或者分成2句话来描述就是：A arose simultaneously with B. But A arose independently of B.

-- by 会员 lottl (2011/7/10 15:45:26)

请问，C中的having been cut 和A中的 that were cut.....and that were arising 为什么是wordy？？？我不懂，请教你一下~

-- by 会员 bob9603 (2011/7/13 23:22:20)

nemiah

Having been 语法上也是可以的，例如，the scientists, having amasses..., now drow the conclusion... 不过有the first 修饰trenches 就awkward 了

mia113

simultaneously with 我查不到这个词组啊……求指点……

-- by 会员 luckysss (2011/1/24 14:47:30)

我们不能说A arose simultaneously of B，只能说A arose simultaneously with B。
同理，不能说A arose independently with B,只能说A arose independently of B。
那这时如果要使两种描述并列，唯一的办法就是：
A arose simultaneously with but independently of B.
=A arose simultaneously with B.But A arose independently of B.

摘自：http://forum.chasedream.com/archiver/GMAT_SC/thread-468207-1.html

jili_111

我也刚做到这题，查了一下朗文和牛津，确实有这个词组的：simultaneous with:
eg: The withdrawal of British troops should be simultaneous with that of US forces


而且还有independent of，意思是：not connected with or influenced by sth; not connected with
eg：The police force should be independent of direct government control


因此这两个介词都是属于跟随副词的固定搭配，而不是和arise一起的固定搭配。

simultaneously with 我查不到这个词组啊……求指点……

-- by 会员 luckysss (2011/1/24 14:47:30)