真题一道

summer614

most of portugal’s 250000 university boycotted classes in a one-day strike to protest a law that reuires them to contribute 330 a year toward the cost of higher education , previously paying 7 per year.

Year , compared to the previously 7 per year, toward the cost of higher education

Year toward the cost of higher education , instead of the 7 per year required previously

这题选b,最后一个为什么不行

JerryGuan

此题，我选第一个选肢：year , compared to the previously 7 per year, toward the cost of higher education

原句A：paying语法上是伴随主句谓语boycotted，语义上它应该和contribute伴随，所以，挥泪告别；

给出的两个选肢，我认为第一个好；原因是它是在比较今年和前一年的情况，并不是如instead of在表达同一事物同一时间状态的两种alternative。

dreadpower

   这个题目选B？？？楼主是指上面一个选项还是下面一个选项？？？我觉得这个题目选上面一个选项

   理由：第一：逻辑意思来看，instead of表示rather than的意思，怎么读这个意思都不如compared to好

          第二：instead of后的内容必须和reuires them to contribute 后的内容平行，但是reuires them to contribute 7 per year required previously就肯定不对了

      TO JerryGuan，我觉得此题的谓语是strike to 而不是boycotted，主语是most of portugal’s 250000 university boycotted classes

weiyu

以下是引用pumpkin在2004-4-25 15:19:00的发言：

Most of portugal’s 250000 university boycotted classes in a one-day strike to protest a law that reuires them to contribute 330 a Year toward the cost of higher education , instead of the 7 per year required previously

两个东东平行的

还请指教

乱说一气

谢谢

我同意Pumpkin MM的意见, 判断方法和我的一点都没区别。我选最后一个。

mariezhu

contribute 330 a year instead of THE 7 per year?

dreadpower

   pumpkin  MM，我觉得最后一个肯定错

   上面我的帖子说了：最根本的理由就是如果平行的话，应该可以写成这样

   requires them to contribute 7 per year required previously

   所以错

JerryGuan

Most of portugal's 250000 university boycotted classes in a one-day strike to protest a law that reuires them to contribute 330 a year , compared to the previously 7 per year, toward the cost of higher education.

25万家大学中的大部分联合起来进了一天的罢工，以抵制一项法律，这项法律要求他们上交330toward the cost of higher education，而前一年却只是每年7。

strike是罢工，名词。

dreadpower

   哦，对，谓语问题是我错了！！谢谢JerryGuan

   

renprince

以下是引用summer614在2004-4-25 10:48:00的发言：

Most of portugal’s 250000 university boycotted classes in a one-day strike to protest a law that reuires them to contribute 330 a year toward the cost of higher education , previously paying 7 per year.

a. year toward the cost of higher education , previously paying 7 per year.

paying没有明确修饰对象, 错

b. Year , compared to the previously 7 per year, toward the cost of higher education

compared to表示两个东东性质完全不同, 但是有个类似的一方面, 错

c. Year toward the cost of higher education , instead of the 7 per year required previously

toward有点怪怪的. 但是偶选这个.

这题选b,最后一个为什么不行

compared to表示两个东东性质完全不同, 但是有个类似的一方面, 错????为什么呢

有什么依据吗？

谢谢

mariezhu

With "compare to" you put the emphasis on similarity 把..比作

while with "compare with" you put the emphasis on difference, 把...和..比较

hope it helps...