弱弱地问一下

1287754

109.(30145-!-item-!-188;#058&004686)

Unlike psychiatrists, who are trained as medical doctors, psychologists have historically been forbidden from prescribing their patients drugs, but in 2002 New Mexico began to grant the privilege of prescribing to licensed, doctoral level psychologists who complete an additional training and certification program.

(A) psychologists have historically been forbidden from prescribing their patients drugs, but in 2002 New Mexico began to grant the privilege of prescribing

(B) psychologists have historically been forbidden to prescribe drugs for their patients, but in 2002 New Mexico began granting prescribing privileges

(C) psychologists have historically been forbidden to prescribe their patients drugs, but in 2002 in New Mexico, the privilege to prescribe began to be granted

(D) historically psychologists have been forbidden from prescribing their patients drugs, but in 2002 New Mexico began to grant the privilege of prescribing

(E) historically psychologists have been forbidden from prescribing drugs for their patients, but in 2002 in New Mexico, they began granting prescribing privileges

选b
但是我选的a啊
forbidden from doing 和forbidden to do 字典里说多可以。。

1287754

讨论帖里米有这道题~~只好在这里问一下

1287754

1287754

aeoluseros

A里面grant the privilege of prescribing to licensed, doctoral level psychologists
to licensed, doctoral level psychologists修饰grant还是prescribing有歧义

1287754

谢谢，好难啊

双鱼游

记住就行了 forbid to 优于 forbid from ，prohibit 后面加 from

chxingsh

我觉得这道题 Prep2007的解释有失偏颇  forbid sb to do sth与 forbid sb from doing sth均成立，那么ADE的形式 forbidden from doing的形式就是对的。因为变为被动语态的话，sb被提前。我认为这道题考察的是 副词historically的位置修饰, 以及 prescribe的用法。

zhangjun1118

* "forbid ... to" is more or less universally preferred to "forbid ... from" in formal written english, so i would assume that the gmat will follow the same preference.

a couple of other points:
* "prescribe drugs for their patients" is much better than "prescribe their patients drugs" (which would be fine in spoken language, but is at best awkward and at worst ambiguous when written)
* "prescribing privileges" is better than "the privilege to prescribe / privilege of prescribing", especially if the latter is placed at the end of the underlined part (as it is in choice a). the problem with the wording in choices (a) and (d) is that it's ambiguous: "...the privilege of prescribing to ... psychologists" could be taken to mean that the prescriptions themselves are being written for psychologists.