学金融

Happy2007

我想上面同学是想说的这个排名吧
不过说实话，edhec家的金融说是全法第一，有点言过其实，这个排名主要说他家的research很厉害，那个risk institute和asset management seminar在业界也算个牌子了
但感觉这个学校太注重research而就业没有跟上，有点往公立方向发展了

zack_wong

I was from EDHEC's RAM and I think that, EDHEC's finance is stronger than that of ESADE.
The only problem is, timing is toooooooo bad. So it is not appropriate to talk about the placement anywhere.

mlchina

不过edhec的alternative 是很出名的。另外阿姆斯特丹大学的金融系的一个牛人（以前是Yale犯了事儿过来的）最近也去了edhec。

zack_wong

hsg2009, u r so funny, we are talking about the comparison between EDHEC and ESADE, no mention be made about HEC or other quants school. U know nothing about alternative, and EDHEC, and u r not even a graduate from France, plz be sealed.
If u wanna talk about anything in Alternative, and u r not satisfied with those positive comments on EDHEC, plz post another topic in CD.

zack_wong

We never show off ourselves and deem EDHEC to be the first Finance school rather than HEC/Engineering Schools in France coz French will never change their mind in general ranking for thousands of years.

Le Poiont made such rank, and I do think it makes some sense, at least much more powful than urs. So u could ignore such bullshit rank but plz save ur words to EDHEC. And EDHEC's Alternative is absolutely No.1 in "Grande Ecole" system, which is a fact from kinds of sources. In addition, nobody wanna attack u, but doubts can be anywhere.

For the placement comparing with ESADE, I no nothing about it, but for EDHEC, yep, first I would like to admit timing is bad and the data sucks, but even so, some Chinese alumni landed good jobs in top institutes. As to u mentioned "海发ad的主", I have no comments on it but, for the "Grande Ecole", I cannot see big difference, at most, u can say, candidates in HEC have brighter GMAT but not the background themselves.

Finally, Hsg2009, I would like to have further discussion with u, but plz be gentle coz the LZ only wanna the result from ESADE and EDHEC, he does not have the alternatives to go for HEC/Engineering. Therefore, plz dont involve other nonsense issues here and focus on this topic.

fsl118

"first I would like to admit timing is bad and the data sucks"  
麻烦ls能不能具体解释一下这句话呢？诚心求教，谢谢了

yy33saint

年景不好，（就业）数据惨淡。

angelxiaoqi

楼上是被EDHEC录了有奖是吗？那ESADE呢？楼上方便留个联系方式吗？我申请了ESADE的 master of marketing呢~~~

终极一G0820

EDHEC法国金融第一在中国人的圈子里说说就算了，在法国没有人会认的。我和我的法国朋友们讨论金融专业选校，首选HEC，其次ESCP，从来没有法国人会因为EDHEC所谓的“全法第一”而去读。法国公司招人也比较对学校的倾向性要大于对专业排名的倾向性，这也是HEC毕业的法国学生为什么那么狂妄的原因。

esade不了解，只是觉得这几年法国高商扩招的太厉害了。

大家可以在法国专门的排名网上看看排名，在这里推荐SMBG，算是比较权威的一个：
http://www.meilleurs-masters.com/master-banque-finance.html?PHPSESSID=222ddaa6325c824d4d1e099fe2b92817

PS 当然，我只是就我所知发表一下个人观点，供大家参考，完全没有贬低edhec的意思。

matthewlu

我今年9月去ESADE. 我现在人在伦敦。msn和邮箱是：matty.lu(at)hotmail.com 多交流！
MATTHEW