[草稿] than比较分类分析 ~~

scarletohara

thanks so much,I peiceive the summary of those friends in CD is more attainable for me than the notes I got from the books which are said to be best seller in GMAT market

addy

mark

silly1986

....

越看越昏啊

skylinepipi

good summary. Just one point : when making judgement of the comparison, pay more attention to the part that is being compared, instead of memorizing these usage.

kellycui

3. The man was always aware, sometimes proudly and sometimes resentfully, that he was a small-town Midwesterner thrust into a world dominated by wealthier, better-educated, and more polished people than he.

哪位NN 能帮忙分析一下这个句子的成分啊, 没有看懂.....

chaser_jane

有点头大。。。。

我也作了那张老长的大全比较题牛贴，感觉只有不补足时完全不会出现混淆的时候才会不补足，其余时候都会补足。。。

 

chaser_jane

第一层主句：主干：The man was always aware,... that+宾语从句

第二层从句：that he was a small-town Midwesterner thrust into a world dominated by wealthier, better-educated, and more polished people than he.

宾语从句主干： he was a small-town midwesterner ......thrust into a world dominated by wealthier, better-educated, and more polished people than he.[thrust过去分词引导定语从句修饰宾语midwesterner]

第三层：比较对象：wealthier better-educated and more polished people [主]dominated[谓] a world[宾]

                             than

                            he[主] dominated[谓] a world[宾]

     这里由于比较的是不同主语，本应做出补足，但是由于省略不会造成歧义，所以省略补出。

PS：要对比较部分同时出现不同主语和宾语的情况谨慎考虑，看是否要做出补出。

Well, that's it. Hope it help~

batmanhm

mark

jh1904

以下是引用hru在2004-4-2 15:10:00的发言：
 几点疑问:

1. 关于（2）than后名词前的介词要补出 , 能否将标题改为"介词短语作状语的比较"???

2.关于(2) 1 :

 1. Aging is a property of all animals that reach a fixed size at maturity, and the variations in life spans among different species are far greater than those among individuals of the same species: a fruit fly is ancient at 40 days, a mouse at 3 years, a horse at 30, a man at 100, and some tortoises at 150. 介宾的比较。

这个句子应该归为主语的比较更合理些, 也就是放到1.1???

3.关于(6)

 1. Although Napoleon’s army entered Russia with far more supplies than for any previous campaign, it had provisions for only twenty-four days.

我对这个句子一直有些疑惑, 因不知是什么成分在比较: with far more supplies than (those) for any previous campaign, 似乎those被省略???

4. 关于

（7）        句子的比较

1. In Japan elderly people are treated with far greater respect than they are in most Western countries.

在这个句子中，they 指代前面的 elderly people in Japan, 是不合逻辑的, 应改为 those???

they 其实是指代elderly people. In Japan应该是修饰整句。若将句子改写如下，语意不变，但更清晰。

Elderly people are treated with far greater respect in Japan than they are in most Western countries.

5. 关于:  9.1 / 7 应归为 9.2 下似乎更合理???

dingxiang

支持楼上的

In Japan elderly people are treated with far greater respect than they are in most Western countries.

我感觉这个句子问题出在语序上面，即像楼上说的In Japan 在句首，则做整句的状语，与我们通常见到的比较不同，这里的比较不满足平行的基本要求。

出于这个原因，如果单单把句子写成

In Japan elderly people are treated with far greater respect than in most Western countries.

那么按照OG的说法，则是这个句子than前后不平行

所以一定要把主谓完整的写出来。

我同意楼上的句子的改法，但我认为如果这样改，完全可以把第二套主谓省略，因为整个句子是状语比较，不会有主谓的歧义

Elderly people are treated with far greater respect in Japan than （they are） in most Western countries.