比较中，谓语动词是have or 带有 will or can 的情况

gtr

这个问题很困扰我：
I have a bigger apple than you do 还是 I have a bigger apple than you have
I have finished homework earlier than you did 还是 I have finished homework earlier than you have
I will eat more apple than you will 还是 I will eat more apple than you do
I will finish homework earlier than you will 还是  I will finish homework earlier than you do
I can eat more apple than you can 还是 I can eat more apple than you do
到底哪个对？

zxkingsey

这个问题很困扰我：
I have a bigger apple than you do 还是 I have a bigger apple than you have
I have finished homework earlier than you did 还是 I have finished homework earlier than you have
I will eat more apple than you will 还是 I will eat more apple than you do
I will finish homework earlier than you will 还是  I will finish homework earlier than you do
I can eat more apple than you can 还是 I can eat more apple than you do
到底哪个对？

-- by 会员 gtr (2010/2/7 23:38:44)

第一个：应该为do
第二个应该为have done
个人意见 欢迎指教

gtr

顶一下，还有谁来发言？：D

gtr

我这礼拜六考试，大家帮忙啊～～顶～

aeoluseros

I have a bigger apple than you do 还是 I have a bigger apple than you have
用do和have都可以。
但是有一道题目很巧妙，gtr可以参考下：

There is a widespread belief in the United States and Western Europe that young people have a smaller commitment to work and a career than their parents and grandparents and that the source of the change lies in the collapse of the "work ethic."
(A) a smaller commitment to work and a career than their parents and grandparents
(B) less of a commitment to work and a career than their parents and grandparents
(C) a smaller commitment to work and a career than that of their parents and grandparents
(D) less of a commitment to work and a career than their parents and grandparents had
(E) a lessening of the commitment to work and a career that their parents and grandparents had
选D。最后用了had，而不是did.
我个人理解，欢迎补充：
前面没有一般过去时(或者表达一般过去时含义的成分)，所以这里不会引起过去完成时的歧义。
其次，have和be都表达了状态，可以回忆一下关于be动词的并列，所以这里用had也是没有问题的。

I have finished homework earlier than you did 还是 I have finished homework earlier than you have
用have

I will eat more apple than you will 还是 I will eat more apple than you do
要看逻辑含义，如果两个人都要开始吃饭，也就是还没吃饭，那么就用will.

I will finish homework earlier than you will 还是  I will finish homework earlier than you do
同上.

I can eat more apple than you can 还是 I can eat more apple than you do
用can.

gtr

I have a bigger apple than you do 还是 I have a bigger apple than you have
用do。
但是有一道题目很巧妙，gtr可以参考下：

There is a widespread belief in the United States and Western Europe that young people have a smaller commitment to work and a career than their parents and grandparents and that the source of the change lies in the collapse of the "work ethic."
(A) a smaller commitment to work and a career than their parents and grandparents
(B) less of a commitment to work and a career than their parents and grandparents
(C) a smaller commitment to work and a career than that of their parents and grandparents
(D) less of a commitment to work and a career than their parents and grandparents had
(E) a lessening of the commitment to work and a career that their parents and grandparents had
选D。最后用了had，而不是did.
我个人理解，欢迎补充：
前面没有一般过去时(或者表达一般过去时含义的成分)，所以这里不会引起过去完成时的歧义。
其次，have和be都表达了状态，可以回忆一下关于be动词的并列，所以这里用had也是没有问题的。

I have finished homework earlier than you did 还是 I have finished homework earlier than you have
用have

I will eat more apple than you will 还是 I will eat more apple than you do
要看逻辑含义，如果两个人都要开始吃饭，也就是还没吃饭，那么就用will.

I will finish homework earlier than you will 还是  I will finish homework earlier than you do
同上.

I can eat more apple than you can 还是 I can eat more apple than you do
用can.

-- by 会员 aeoluseros (2010/2/9 4:39:03)

谢谢，让我好好体会一下
其实你引用的那道题，就是我感到很迷惑，最终发了这个帖子的原因，呵呵。本来还挺清楚，前几天看了那道题，虽然知道肯定D正确，但就对于是have 还是 did头晕了。谢谢～

ssyy23

less of a commitment to work and a career than their parents and grandparents had
had不对啊，应该是did才对吧？

sunyuwei

aeoluseros 发表于 2010-2-9 04:39
I have a bigger apple than you do 还是 I have a bigger apple than you have用do和have都可以。但是有一 ...

大神，时隔这么多年看到了这个帖子 对于补出had 还是did 我其实还是有点困惑，你的想法有变吗？还是有更好的解释？
你说的“have和be都表达了状态，可以回忆一下关于be动词的并列，所以这里用had也是没有问题的”是什么意思，不太理解~~