GWD6-Q34，崩溃了，到底选什么……

LUCIE_SIMON

GWD6-Q34:

The market for recycled commodities like aluminum and other metals remain strong despite economic changes in the recycling industry.

A.    commodities like aluminum and other metals remain

B.    commodities like those of aluminum and other metals are remaining

C.    commodities such as aluminum and other metals remains

D.    commodities, such as aluminum and other metals, remain

E.     commodities, like the commodities of aluminum and other metals, remains

 

GWD这里的答案是C.我一开始也是这么想的。但是前不久看到帖子，上面激烈的争论着，说答案是E，我选了E，GWD的答案又是C。到底是什么啊？？？？以前的帖子也没找到……请NN们来告诉我正确的思路啊……

floridadream

like 不能用于列举  句子的主语是market 所以动词要单数第三人称 所以C

LUCIE_SIMON

http://forum.chasedream.com/dispbbs.asp?boardID=23&ID=45197&page=3

check this out~~~i find the link~~

LUCIE_SIMON

41. The market for recycled commodities like aluminum and other metals remain strong despite economic changes in the recycling industry. A. commodities like aluminum and other metals remain B. commodities like those of aluminum and other metals are remaining C. commodities such as aluminum and other metals remains D. commodities,such as aluminum and other metals, remains E. commodities, like those of aluminum and other metals, remains

偶开始选了C，D肯定不对，理由和PumpkinMM一样．　commondies such as中间不能加逗号否则意思不清．但是E的those是对的；

commondities such as aluminum and other metals商品例如铝和其它金属．铝和金属不是商品．所以those of..逻辑意思正确，铝质和其它金属的商品

from weiyu

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-5-3 22:54:36编辑过]

joywu1221

E is wrong. those of aluminum and other metals意思不对等。铝制商品和其他金属？？？两个概念不对等，不能用and连接。E怎么看还是错

AlienX

umm...
個人還是認為C對E錯.
如果比較熟悉trading的xdjm可能會知道commodities trading, commodities trading常trade的是木材, gold, metal之類的東東.  所以commodities such as aluminum and other metals沒問題.
aluminum是metal的一種(希望我的chemistry knowledge還對), 所以E中的aluminum and other metals沒問題.  反而commodities of aluminum and other metals很wordy.

wanglizero

举例用like肯定错

一定要such as,ABE排除

主语是market，所以谓语remains单数形式

而且举例such as前不能+逗号

反衬

C为正解。

like通常用于名词间的相似性比较，不能用于举例。

举例用such as,

 C当中，aluminum and other metals remains 平行对称，而且都从属于commodities商品（铝本身就是可以买卖的金属）

按照E选项的逻辑，like表示比较，是比较两种概念间的相似性，反而不对称,因为主语是market，而like后面是两种产品。

E这样改更合理：两个market间形成概念的对等。

The market for recycled commodities, like the market of aluminum and other metals, remains  strong despite economic changes in the recycling industry.

 

LUCIE_SIMON

谢谢楼上们的解答~~~

苹果夹心派