GWD5-14（老题新问~！没有人清楚解释过这道题呢）

LWfighting

GWD5-Q14: GWD-TN-3-14：

Even though more money was removed out of stock funds in July as in any month since October 1987, sales of fund shares in July were not as low as an industry trade group had previously estimated.

A.      as in any month since October 1987, sales of fund shares in July were not as low as

B.       as had been in any other month since October 1987, sales of fund shares in July were not as low as what

C.      than there was in any other month since October 1987, sales of fund shares in July were not as low as that which

D.      than in any month since October 1987, sales of fund shares in July were not as low as

E.       than in any other month since October 1987, sales of fund shares in July were not as low as what

这道题困惑我N久了...希望大家帮帮忙哦~~~而且好奇怪哦 前两个问题居然没人问过...是我没搜到讨论帖，还是大家都懂了 就我没懂 所以第一个问啊~~~！？

（1）为什么前半句用了since，但是没有用完成时呢？而是用的was

（2）为什么所有的答案都是用了not as ...as呢？应该是not so ...as吧~~~怎么回事儿~！？怎么回事儿？！

（3）还有，看了大家之前的帖子，貌似都在讨论D与E...问题纠结于

【1】July在 October 1987之前还是之后

【2】what是怎么回事儿...到底省还是不省...

貌似没有谁清楚地解释过这两个问题呢...关于【1】我觉得应该是在 October 1987之后吧...如果就比较当年的JULY和 October 的情况 还用大动干戈滴把年代搬出来吗？当然这也只是感觉...也没有具体依据...

哪位NN解释一下呗~~~谢咯~~~

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-4-23 20:19:20编辑过]

LWfighting

怎么没人理我捏~~~555....战友们帮帮忙啊^^

kidyrain

因为开头未划线部分有more，所以abc都被排除了，至于d的话，因为月份要跟它自己之外的月份比，所以要用any other,而e的话，what省略是可以的，但是这个是最没有correctiveness错误的选项了

LWfighting

以下是引用kidyrain在2009-4-23 21:27:00的发言：
因为开头未划线部分有more，所以abc都被排除了，至于d的话，因为月份要跟它自己之外的月份比，所以要用any other,而e的话，what省略是可以的，但是这个是最没有correctiveness错误的选项了

呵呵 5555....我不是问的这些问题啦~~~但是还是很谢谢你哟~~~

嘿嘿 麻烦再看看我的问题吧...帮帮忙解答呗^^

aeoluseros

since October 1987是修饰in any other month的，因为be removed out有in July修饰了，这也是之所以前面不用现在完成时.
否定句里面not so...as和not as...as都对.但是肯定句里不能用not so...as.
最后的what可以省.举个类似的例子:The film is not as intersting as I expected.

markhuang111

sales of fund shares ...not as low as what

比较对象对等，和industry trade group had previously estimated估计的sales比较

WhiteScarf

答案是D

since已經排除七月，從1987年到這個月為止，所以不用加other

kevin2ff

July 应该在之后吧， 关于what省不省的问题，我做题的经验感觉是sales of fund shares in July were not as low as （whatan industry trade group had） previously estimated， 如果要省去的话 应该是省略括号里的， 不会加an industry tade group had, 只要后面的修饰就可。 还有的比较也是 如果比较的对象是相同的，保留状语即可.