选校纠结 Tuck vs UCLA vs Ross vs Duke

vincentwu821

以下是引用tanner_cai在2009-3-27 13:15:00的发言：

还用考虑吗？

当然选tuck啦，我的dream school啊。

ps lz真牛啊

麻烦讲讲理由啊～Tuck真的有那么好？

vincentwu821

再顶一下，大家多多拍砖啊

flytiti

关注

貌似tuck在国内知名度也一般阿

duke的国内知名度倒是好些吧

也许分圈内圈外吧，可能国内的某些圈子也认可tuck比duke好呢

vincentwu821

以下是引用flytiti在2009-3-27 15:48:00的发言：

关注

貌似tuck在国内知名度也一般阿

duke的国内知名度倒是好些吧

也许分圈内圈外吧，可能国内的某些圈子也认可tuck比duke好呢

这正是我的担心之一啊， tuck在非美国本土似乎名气很不够？

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-3-27 17:45:20编辑过]

pega09

以下是引用vincentwu821在2009-3-27 17:45:00的发言：

这正是我的担心之一啊， tuck在非美国本土似乎名气很不够？

有曾子墨,虽然貌似是达茅本科, 给国内带来些知名度.如果在美国,确实是非常好的,不过我老板前几天确实跟我说过那边白人精英文化未必适合亚洲人. 我的面试官也说校友圈在中国很有限.

Ross的亚洲氛围可能是前十里最好的,校友圈子也是最大的. Duke的长处之一是health care,感觉实力上要比Ross弱,但环境好,听说是绿森林包围的学校?

苞米

I am not sure which school you should ultimately choose, but I am CERTAIN that most “facts” listed by previous posts are quite inaccurate and misleading.

If I were you, I would seriously consider between Ross and Tuck. To my knowledge, Anderson and Fuqua have never ever been known as general management schools. You may call them finance schools or whatever, but general management school? They are not even close. The beautiful part of Tuck is its overall reputation, and finance probably. In the good old days, everybody got into the b-school to do with finance, and you cannot really rule out that possibility even the market is as horrible as right now. You may well change in your mind at a later point, and Tuck offers you better chance if you do. I really love Ross’s MBA program and I think the MAP is out of this world. Their general management has been what they are famous for, and the consulting is very decent. However, you should always bear in mind that all these facts are arguably built upon the diminished glory of the Detroit’s big Three. And Ann Arbor will suffer seriously for sure if anything bad happens fifty miles away.

emptyalley

对你的第一目标来说，Ross 或 Tuck
但是目前经济很差，我还是建议不要以哪个实现“最理想”的目标而以哪个实现你可接受的最可能的目标（保底目标）为主要考量。
另：即使你去Ross，在经济光景很好的情况下，进美国本土或欧洲business consulting的中国大陆的也很少

filman

如果从reputation in the US来讲,Tuck无疑是最佳的选择。

如果考虑到就业问题，我建议楼主向学校所要Chinese alumni的job placement report（不是那种简单的统计，而是具体到公司名称和职务）只是不知道学校是否会提供。

通过这些数据，你可以很清楚地有一个big picture of Chinese alumni network，相信可以有效地帮助LZ做出决定。

（PS.幸好我申请的学校基本上拉开了档次，不用揪结了^_^)

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-3-28 8:22:25编辑过]

vincentwu821

以下是引用苞米在2009-3-28 1:49:00的发言：

I am not sure which school you should ultimately choose, but I am CERTAIN that most “facts” listed by previous posts are quite inaccurate and misleading.

If I were you, I would seriously consider between Ross and Tuck. To my knowledge, Anderson and Fuqua have never ever been known as general management schools. You may call them finance schools or whatever, but general management school? They are not even close. The beautiful part of Tuck is its overall reputation, and finance probably. In the good old days, everybody got into the b-school to do with finance, and you cannot really rule out that possibility even the market is as horrible as right now. You may well change in your mind at a later point, and Tuck offers you better chance if you do. I really love Ross’s MBA program and I think the MAP is out of this world. Their general management has been what they are famous for, and the consulting is very decent. However, you should always bear in mind that all these facts are arguably built upon the diminished glory of the Detroit’s big Three. And Ann Arbor will suffer seriously for sure if anything bad happens fifty miles away.

 Thanks so much for your insights! I got something inside from your words...

vincentwu821

以下是引用emptyalley在2009-3-28 4:42:00的发言：

对你的第一目标来说，Ross 或 Tuck
但是目前经济很差，我还是建议不要以哪个实现“最理想”的目标而以哪个实现你可接受的最可能的目标（保底目标）为主要考量。
另：即使你去Ross，在经济光景很好的情况下，进美国本土或欧洲business consulting的中国大陆的也很少

 明白。所以更为实际的目标，应该是进入M/B/B等Tier1的咨询，但接受被派回国工作的安排？

咨询的确比较适合我的个性及长处，问题是时间久了真的会累，以及有感觉不是真的在做business。更多的是做PPT和presentation而已。。。

如果我专注于第二目标，即希望能留在国外进入行业做general management，Tuck会不会也是比较合适的选择？