TT-GWD 2-33 求助

271632852

creatokay 发表于 2012-3-30 20:57
我虽然懂这题大体为什么A错了，但是觉得5页下来没有一个很好很好的归纳。    首先是A选项的each  ...

我也知道each引导的强调型独立主格结构这个东西，是用于强调句尾的复数名词，但reserve不是复数啊，而且觉得each那个独立主格结构用来强调reserve是不是也不合理，求指教

zyx20085

this should be (e).

the other four choices all misuse "which" (or "each of which", whose modifier properties are the same as those of "which").
in (a), "each of which" doesn't refer to anything at all (it seems to refer to "reserve", but that doesn't make any sense)
in (b), "which" refers to the shark's jaws (this doesn't make sense)
in (c) and (d), "each one of which" refers to the shark's jaws (this doesn't make sense)

also:
(a) and (b) have the wrong meaning: the placement of the "when"/"whenever" clause suggests that the teeth are only there when another tooth is lost or worn down.
(c) has subject-verb disagreement ("each one of which" is singular, but "are" is plural).
(d) is a sentence fragment.

elenaknight

wildmantomba 发表于 2012-5-8 11:02
看完5页帖子，整理一下1、logical predication：排除A、B时间状语误置，导致意思变成“当牙齿脱落时，其他 ...

好棒的整理！

elenaknight

271632852 发表于 2013-5-13 15:27
我也知道each引导的强调型独立主格结构这个东西，是用于强调句尾的复数名词，但reserve不是复数啊，而且 ...

each指代的是teeth，不是reserve啊。

shjtSAIF

gmat928 发表于 2010-2-24 00:55
E。   In the shark’s jaws, many spare teeth lie in seemingly limitless reserve, each one re ...

同意！               

LMS0617

Mark一下！               

ai559031

(A)Hunting limits for snow geese were imposed many years ago in response to a sharp decline in the population of snow geese.

獵捕限制行之有年，但獵捕數有沒有過門檻沒講，
有過移除限制才有用，沒過移除也沒用，
因此無法反駁原文。

(B)It has been many years since the restriction led to the hunting season for snow geese being closed earlier than the scheduled date.

「據上次因為達到獵捕限制而提早結束狩獵季已隔好幾年」

言下之意就是這些年來根本獵不到那麼多數量的雪鵝，
既然獵不到那麼多解除限制也還是獵不到，
因此對於其他鳥類復育的幫助自然沒有什麼用。

(C)The number of snow geese taken by hunters each year has grown every year for several years.

類似A，
每年獵捕數雖增加，有沒有過門檻卻沒講，
有過移除才有用，沒過移除也沒用，
無法反駁原文。

(D)As their population has increased, snow geese have recolonized wintering grounds that they had not used for several seasons.

雪鵝分佈變廣，但並不保證獵捕數會相對變多或變少，
自然也推不出關於獵捕限制一事。

(E)In the snow gooses winter habitats, the goose faces no significant natural predation.

類似D，
雪鵝沒有天敵，不保證獵捕數會相對變多或變少，
推不出關於獵捕限制一事

Cynth1aC

这道题答案是E
在付费的Prep 里做到了。