ChaseDream
搜索
返回列表 发新帖
楼主: 蘑菇
打印 上一主题 下一主题

[录取汇报] In @ Duke

[精华] [复制链接]
31#
发表于 2008-11-16 13:01:00 | 只看该作者

Early Decision vs. Early Action

Early admissions programs can be divided into two categories: early decision (ED) and early action (EA). Single choice early action (SCEA) programs are a particular kind of early action program.8 R! ^- S) M& T
" P& I4 Q& @) Y' n$ z$ F
ED and EA programs both involve an earlier application deadline than the normal admissions process does, and (as their names imply) earlier notification of admissions decisions. Accepted applicants enjoy several benefits. A high school student who already knows that she has been accepted to her top choice college can take chances she might not otherwise. She might take a challenging college-level course that she would pass on if she were worried that her spring grades might affect her college applications. Another advantage, of course, is that she and her family have more time to plan for her move to college, and to arrange financial aid and housing.
However, the most attractive aspect of early admissions programs is that colleges and universities tend to admit a significantly higher percentage of the early applicant pool than they do of the normal applicant pool ¨C in other words, there is the possibility that your chances of being accepted as an early admissions candidate are better than they would be as a regular applicant. The most selective colleges currently admit 25% to 50% of their total students from the early admissions pool. In recent years, as many as 40% of freshmen at Ivy League schools have been early admissions applicants.! }6 L$ I. S; L6 i1 U+ _& z
2 I* X7 y: [& S) g# P
There is, of course, a catch to all this: the issue of binding decisions.
T

Early Decision (Binding), H; N5 u# E8 T/ R
Early decision (ED) programs are usually binding. 'Binding' means that the applicant promises from the start that they will attend the school if their application is accepted. It is not an obligation to be taken lightly, since schools honor one another's binding decisions. If you renege on an early decision obligation to one school, it is unlikely that another competitive school will accept you. Students can seek release from an early decision obligation on the grounds of financial hardship, if the financial aid package they are offered is genuinely inadequate; however, the burden of proof in these cases is on the student. (By the way, an important drawback to early decision admissions is that they leave applicants with no leverage to negotiate a better financial aid package ¨C the school knows you can't go anywhere else.)

Early decision applicants are expected to submit only one early decision application to one school. They can submit applications to other schools under normal application procedures, but agree that they will withdraw all those applications if they are accepted to the early decision school.. o; h3 B) @7 m4 o2 W2 e  }0 }$ {7 A
8 \7 ?& Z; h3 c' A' [9 W9 H* ?! s+ U9 B

Early Action (Non Binding)
Early admissions programs which do not ask applicants to commit to attending if they are accepted are generally known as Early action (EA) programs. In our view, these are a better deal for most applicants. They give students the benefits of early notification without the obligations of early decision. Even if accepted, students are free to apply to other schools and to compare financial aid offers. Single choice early action (SCEA) programs specifically require students not to make EA applications to other schools, although they are free to apply elsewhere under the regular admissions round. In recent years, several of the country's most selective universities (including Harvard, Yale, and Stanford) have adopted non-binding early admissions programs.

( `  @& n/ F, @2 B5 l* b
Our Recommendations
Early admissions programs can be very advantageous to college applicants, depending on their profile and situation. A high school student who is sure of what school they want to go to, and whose junior year grades, extracurricular activities, etc., are strong enough to secure admission, can benefit from early admissions. However, we do not encourage clients with any questions at all about their college preferences to seek a binding early decision from any school, regardless of how much better the statistical chances of acceptance may be under an early decision program. Keep in mind that you're not just being asked to indicate a school preference; you're being asked to forego all other options and to commit yourself to spending four years (and tens of thousands of dollars) at a particular institution. That's a big decision for anyone to make. It should only be undertaken with the best possible information and advice, and without undue deadline pressure.

32#
发表于 2008-11-16 13:10:00 | 只看该作者

蘑菇,我这才知道为什么Tuck的是early action,而Columbia和Duke的early decision

按道理来说一个人只能申请一个early decision的,因为这是binding的。不知道你的case应该怎么办。

我还有申请的是Tuck的early action,还有一些其他学校的regular round,应该不会冲突。但是如果按照ED的游戏规则,Duke会通知其他学校我们被ED录取,然后被其他学校录取的机会就几乎不可能了。

可惜当时没有太深究这个EA和ED。现在似乎没有其他的option了。你可以看看其他学校的decision是怎样的,有没有验证ED的游戏规则。不过,就算最坏的情况,我们还是可以做同学的。抱抱!

33#
发表于 2008-11-16 13:42:00 | 只看该作者
Duke 网上明明是写Early Action, 但为什么是binding呢?这有点像是故意要误导人似的。
34#
 楼主| 发表于 2008-11-16 20:58:00 | 只看该作者
以下是引用pixy_why在2008-11-16 13:10:00的发言:

蘑菇,我这才知道为什么Tuck的是early action,而Columbia和Duke的early decision

按道理来说一个人只能申请一个early decision的,因为这是binding的。不知道你的case应该怎么办。

我还有申请的是Tuck的early action,还有一些其他学校的regular round,应该不会冲突。但是如果按照ED的游戏规则,Duke会通知其他学校我们被ED录取,然后被其他学校录取的机会就几乎不可能了。

可惜当时没有太深究这个EA和ED。现在似乎没有其他的option了。你可以看看其他学校的decision是怎样的,有没有验证ED的游戏规则。不过,就算最坏的情况,我们还是可以做同学的。抱抱!

嗯~~~现在我就只能再等等Columbia,应该这几天就出来了

无论接受的是CBS还是duke,都意味着我不可能去其它学校了~~~~~

埃 我的Wharton,我的Kellogg。。。。。。。

==============================================================

不过想到可以跟你做同学,我还是很高兴得~~~~

hohohoho

35#
发表于 2008-11-16 23:40:00 | 只看该作者
以下是引用inlovesummer在2008-11-16 3:04:00的发言:
find this "如果在ED1和EA期间申请大于一所的学校,出现被两所学校录取以上的情况,会出现你要拒绝一方,但是当你拒绝后学校会在教育信息数据库中共享ED1 EA申请者信息,如发现申请多所学校一般会被所有学校取消录取资格,或被列入学校共享commonapp名单,将不得在以后进行早期申请.SSN将被记录."
蘑菇,  问题比二选一要严重! 我们是SUPPOSED只能申请一个ED的。如上面的段落说讲的, 如果你不马上推出COLUMBIA的话,你就有两个ED, 你必须REJECT其中一个ED, 而当你REJECT任何一个ED, 你的资料都会在ED库里,那么另一个录取你的学校也会收回OFFER。 你得在COLUMBIA出来之前查清楚啊。 
36#
发表于 2008-11-16 23:44:00 | 只看该作者
以下是引用lich在2008-11-16 13:42:00的发言:
Duke 网上明明是写Early Action, 但为什么是binding呢?这有点像是故意要误导人似的。

上面写了如果录取,要从别的学校退回申请. ah yue,还好DUKE也是个好学校,要不然真是亏大了!
37#
发表于 2008-11-17 00:43:00 | 只看该作者
以下是引用inlovesummer在2008-11-16 23:40:00的发言:
蘑菇,  问题比二选一要严重! 我们是SUPPOSED只能申请一个ED的。如上面的段落说讲的, 如果你不马上推出COLUMBIA的话,你就有两个ED, 你必须REJECT其中一个ED, 而当你REJECT任何一个ED, 你的资料都会在ED库里,那么另一个录取你的学校也会收回OFFER。 你得在COLUMBIA出来之前查清楚啊。 

如此这般严重?幸好没有申两个Early round。不过我觉得这个是否也是个指导性的说法呢?inlovesummer哪里查到的呢?这么重要的信息,各个B-School也不放在application的页面上啊。

38#
发表于 2008-11-17 02:22:00 | 只看该作者

如这里讲,他们有个内部的资料库。 各个学校都会看到

我又有听说,如果你拒绝一个ED学校, 它会发BLACKLIST给其他学校。

39#
发表于 2008-11-17 02:23:00 | 只看该作者

美国人也不是那么容易忽悠的。 他们有他们的办法防止学生违规

40#
 楼主| 发表于 2008-11-17 22:23:00 | 只看该作者

这样子的阿

~~~~~Sigh

您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 立即注册

Mark一下! 看一下! 顶楼主! 感谢分享! 快速回复:

NTU MBA
近期活动

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()

手机版|ChaseDream|GMT+8, 2025-12-28 17:46
京公网安备11010202008513号 京ICP证101109号 京ICP备12012021号

ChaseDream 论坛

© 2003-2025 ChaseDream.com. All Rights Reserved.

返回顶部