大全-39 求助

rockmax

大全-39.        According to a ruling by the state supreme court, the owner of polluted land is liable for the cleanup of the property even if the owner did not have the responsibility that pollution occurred before the title changed hands.

(A) the owner did not have the responsibility that pollution

(B) the owner is not responsible for pollution that

(C) it was not the owner’s responsibility that pollution would have

(D) the responsibility of the owner is not that pollution（B）

(E) the responsibility was not the owner’s that pollution would have

答案是B,   

C 为什么不对?

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-7-8 22:59:23编辑过]

我爱周末

1) Be responsible for sth 对什么负责.

2) 时态不一致. 这是个陈述形式,到土地交接的时候,都不是owner的responsiblity.

3) 仅供参考和讨论.

    逻辑大意不对: B 句, 即使土地的拥有者不对已经发生的污染负责.

                  C 句: would have done sth 是虚拟时态,表示与过去发生的相反.

                       翻译为: 即使土地有污染,也不是土地拥有者的责任.

rockmax

以下是引用我爱周末在2008-7-8 23:26:00的发言：

1) Be responsible for sth 对什么负责.

2) 时态不一致. 这是个陈述形式,到土地交接的时候,都不是owner的responsiblity.

3) 仅供参考和讨论.

    逻辑大意不对: B 句, 即使土地的拥有者不对已经发生的污染负责.

                  C 句: would have done sth 是虚拟时态,表示与过去发生的相反.

                       翻译为: 即使土地有污染,也不是土地拥有者的责任.

谢谢 我爱周末 的解答, 

realshaoling

以下是引用rockmax在2008-7-8 22:59:00的发言：

大全-39.        According to a ruling by the state supreme court, the owner of polluted land is liable for the cleanup of the property even if the owner did not have the responsibility that pollution occurred before the title changed hands.

(A) the owner did not have the responsibility that pollution

(B) the owner is not responsible for pollution that

(C) it was not the owner’s responsibility that pollution would have

(D) the responsibility of the owner is not that pollution（B）

(E) the responsibility was not the owner’s that pollution would have

答案是B,   

C 为什么不对?

I choose b

划线外说“the owner ”对清扫土地负责

b： 尽管the owner不用对污染负责，这个污染在什么之前已经发生了；语义合理

c：it 指代什么，不清楚，responsibility后面的“that” 指代也不清楚