top10的学校都要求IBT110以上马？还是只有HBS这样？

hsuehM

But you can't say a guy with P&G experience is not as good as a guy with 2 years IB experience either just as you can't say P&G or Coca Cola CEO is not as good as some MD in an I-Bank. Every industry needs leadership. And most people know that a large proportion of admitted HBS students are from banking and consulting industries. So it's fair to everyone obviously.

hsuehM

以下是引用sunjie38在2008-8-8 13:13:00的发言：
hbs里面其实也是参差不齐

But it's still good to get admitted. What a sour grape you are.

pathseeker

At my school, upon graduation, the best people go on to top Investment
banks and management consulting firms. Second best move on to Big 4
accountancies. Third tier join GE in its vairous leadership development
programs. And the rest are disbursed across P&G, Johnson &
Johnson type of companies. These people in firms like P&G are below
average students in college. I personally feel it is extrememly unfair
that they are even considered for admission into top business schools
just because they bring some so called "diversity" to the programs.
They bring down the intellectual quality of the class and rarely do
IB/MC veterans in business schools want to pair with them in group work
if they can choose. To keep it in mind, many many and many senior executives of
companies like P&G are top IB/MC veterans.

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-8-10 13:31:18编辑过]

gonghao

那照pathseeker的话来说，只需要设立金融学院就可以了。

MBA本身就是对你们金融投行同学的贬低，既然如此，你们又何苦来和我们这些来自P&G和J&J的人为伍。