consider to be 到底有没有错?

dormousedzc

79. George Sand (Aurore Lucile Dupin) was one of the first European writers to consider the rural poor to be legitimate subjects for literature and portray these with sympathy and respect in her novels.
    

1. to be legitimate subjects for literature and portray these
               
2. should be legitimate subjects for literature: portray these
                   

3. as being legitimate subjects for literature an portraying them
                   

4. as if they were legitimate subjects for literal; and portray them
                   

5. legitimate subjects for literature and to portray them
               

OG说A.选项  to be is unnecessary; 那么我想问consider to be到底算不算错呢? 如果没有consider sb. sth.的双宾结构可选,可否用consider sb. to be 的结构来替代呢?  甚感困惑,请NN指点.感激不尽

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-11-17 22:00:57编辑过]

bandito

可以说consider XX to be，也可以说considered to be。但是不可以说consider to be。因为如果中间不加东西，consider() to be只能作为被动过去式去修饰前面的词汇。否则没有意义。

rockmax

1．
            Consider sb./sth+.(as)+形容词/名词。其中，as可以省略。
                
We consider him honest.我们认为他很诚实。
                
At first they considered me as a doctor.起初他们认为我是医生。
                
2.  consider+sb./sth.+不定式。（构成复合宾语结构,）其中，通常不定时为to be (可以省略)或者完成式。

We consider this matter to be very important.我们认为这件事很重要。
            
We all consider him to have stolen the bike.我们都认为他偷了自行车。
        

Consider作“认为”讲, consider ... as/ to be.... 都可以,   as // to be 可以省略.  既然以简洁为主, 就没必要用as . to be 了.

WALLMAGE

在GMAT SC考试环境中，只需牢记这3点即可：

consider/make n1 n2; （别管as的事, 可以就认为有as是错的) At first they considered me a doctor(引用楼上例句做修改)

consider/make n+adj;  (别管to be的事，可以就认为有to be是错的) i consider the story true.

consider/make it adj to do (无it不能用to do) i considered it good to go out for a walk.

make与consider用法相同.

根据以上规则排除ABCD，E符合 consider n1 n2结构

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-7-26 18:03:27编辑过]

feifeizoe

我觉得这里A选项的consider A to be B并没有错误。只是比较Consider A B，更加简洁，因此也就比较好。

A选项中关键的错误在于宾语的指代错误，没有使用them，而是用了these。

RTP

WALLMAGE 说的很清楚：）赞

琦乐无穷

谢谢！

Isabella雪

WALLMAGE 发表于 2008-7-26 18:02
在GMAT SC考试环境中，只需牢记这3点即可：consider/make n1 n2; （别管as的事, 可以就认为有as是错的) At  ...

请问consider to have done这个用法呢？出现这个的话，算对还是错啊？