[求助]GWD-18-11

lovejulie_0

prep上这道题是选c啊

ken178

up. 答案是A还是C??????

lkbd

OG12 SC的第138题，答案就是C没错的

番茄蛋花汤

245. (25627-!-item-!-188;#058&001618)     (GWD-18-Q11)



In no other historical sighting did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation as did its return in 1910–1911

A. did its return in 1910–1911

B. had its 1910–1911 return

C. in its return of 1910–1911

D. its return of 1910–1911 did

E. its return in 1910–1911



根据前文种no的位置，看出此句想对比的内容为时间,，只有C选项在比较时间点，其他四个选项都是在比return这件事。



（需注意A、D如果其中一个对，则另一个也是对的。如比较点正确，这两个选项的写法都是对的。）

黄卓明博客上的~

veralove327

OG12上选C:
[tr][td=292]The single subject of this sentence is Halley's
Comet, and its single verb phrase is did cause. The
comparison presented by the sentence is between
adverbial phrases describing times when the
comet was seen. Grammatically, the items being
compared are parallel prepositional phrases
beginning with the preposition in: in no other
sighting and in its return in 1910-1911. This is the
clearest, most economical way of presenting the
information. The options that introduce a second
verb (did or had) violate the parallelism and
introduce a comparison between the comet itself
(subject of the verb did cause) and the comet's
return (subject of the verb did or had).[/td][/tr]

Vivian1091

这题答案是C。一开始对AD为啥错有疑问，自己想了想，贴下自己的理解：

正确答案调整语序 和 加了省略部分 的内容后的句子：
Halley's Comet caused such a worldwide sensation in no other historical sighting as in its return of 1910-1911.

试比较
Halley's Comet didn't caused such a worldwide sensation in other historical sighting as its return in 1910-1911 caused.

结论就是：因为否定 在 介词短语，所以就比较介词短语； 如果 否定在 谓语动词， 就 比较 主谓。这是很细微的差别了，因为 这三个选项语法上都没啥错误了，只能通过细微 的语义差别来判断哪个更好。

至于有的 地方说的比较对象 不 平行，这个我看不出来，所以就用的笨办法。

IVY7W

这题PREP选 的是C啊，解释说的是比较的是in no other sighting这个短语啊，而且no other后面才是比较的内容吧，倒装强调了啊，我觉得就是选C啊。。

abc791201064

云在青天水在瓶 发表于 2007-9-20 18:41
GWD-18-Q11In no other historical sighting did Halley’s comet cause such a worldwide sensation as di ...

OG题目好像 严格按照OG官方OA来

sherry92

我终于搞明白的说~~~~分析：As前面是一个倒装结构，意思是哈雷彗星从未引起过和1910-1911回归这一时刻一样多的全球关注了。其他的historical sighting中哈雷彗星所引起关注的程度远不如1910-1911这段时间内多。那么as之前的句子是以哈雷彗星为主语的动宾结构，那么根据平行原则，as之后的句子也要是一个以哈雷彗星为主语的动宾结构。再考虑倒装，则最好的方法是as之后跟随in的介词短语结构。
A：in 1910-1911推后了，按道理应该使用正常语序。而did位于句前却是倒装的用法，句子结构混乱。并且主语是its return而不是哈雷彗星。
B：没有in的介词结构却使用倒装是语法错误。
C：正确，可以理解后面省略了did it cause a worldwide sensation。
D、E：主语是its return，错误。且D中使用正常语序，不如倒装好。