[讨论]no和not any

easydudu

原题：In 1978 only half the women granted child support by a court received the amount awarded; at least as much as a million and more others had not any support agreements whatsoever.

(B) at least as much as more than a million others had no

(C) more than a million others had not any

(D) more than a million others had no

(E) there was at least a million or more others without any

正确答案：D

分析：排除B、E是必然的，不用多说。但是C和D的唯一区别就在是用no还是not any，但本人倾向选not any，原因是尽量贴近原题中的表达。尽管我知道any在肯定句中是强烈语气表达，不能随意删除，在否定句中不是。

是否是因为have no support是比have not any support更优选的表达方式的原因？请各位NN赐教。

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-11-4 22:21:26编辑过]

Lujs8061

我觉的因为后面是supports, 是复数，而not any + 单数名词， 所以选 no support agreements.

遥远的绿洲

not any表达复杂,一般用No来代替

7barbara1986

个人认为因为had是在这是实意动词是有的意思，要用否定的话就应该是didn't have
而这里用had not any不就不对了嘛。。。所以就直接接no咯~~~~

YY_lalala

XDF的说法是：能用一个词的就不要用两个词，能不出现的就不要出现

举的例子包括: not any - no; have the abiliy to do 劣于 be able to 劣于 can 等

虽然比较绝对，但是还是有道理的。绝大多数题目都适用

stevegt

以下是引用easydudu在2007-6-21 19:47:00的发言：

原题：In 1978 only half the women granted child support by a court received the amount awarded; at least as much as a million and more others had not any support agreements whatsoever.

(B) at least as much as more than a million others had no

(C) more than a million others had not any

(D) more thana million others had no

(E) there was at least a million or more others without any

正确答案：D

分析：排除B、E是必然的，不用多说。但是C和D的唯一区别就在是用no还是not any，但本人倾向选not any，原因是尽量贴近原题中的表达。尽管我知道any在肯定句中是强烈语气表达，不能随意删除，在否定句中不是。

是否是因为have no support是比have not any support更优选的表达方式的原因？请各位NN赐教。

not any=no 而且NO比not any简洁.所以一般有not any 和no同时出现的情况,就选no

easydudu

以下是引用Lujs8061在2007-6-21 20:05:00的发言：

我觉的因为后面是supports, 是复数，而not any + 单数名词， 所以选 no support agreements.

有问题哎，看不懂。

正确答案的后面明明是support嘛，你是不是想说agreements是复数啊？

easydudu

不过，其他楼的回复都看懂了，非常感谢。