[求助]OG73并列问题请教

pangpangshin

73. The British Admiralty and the War Office met in March 1892 to consider a possible Russian attempt to seize Constantinople and how they would have to act militarily to deal with them.

(A)  how they would have to act militarily to deal with them

(B)   how to deal with them if military action would be necessary

(C)  what would be necessary militarily for dealing with such an event

(D)  what military action would be necessary in order
                    to deal with such an event

(E)   the necessity of what kind of military action in
                    order to take for dealing with it

 

答案为D

 

请问大家a possible Russian attempt to seize Constantinople and what military action would be necessary in order
                                        to deal with such an event

 

这不是名词和句子的并列么?这似乎不符合并列的习惯啊?

 

请指教!

 

gloomyecs

這題似乎由代詞下手會比較好做，而且由題意，後面的並列都當consider的受詞，我是這樣理解的

meggie_xm

后面what引导的不是句子，是what引导的短语，相当于名词。

例如：what i want is a happy life

what is difficult to understand id the noun ……

lz参考。

pandaeyes

e为啥不对阿  不明显是名词么

fy_w

the necessity of what kind of military action， what 引导的从句没有谓语， 从句不完整，

pangpangshin

以下是引用meggie_xm在2007-5-4 7:17:00的发言：

后面what引导的不是句子，是what引导的短语，相当于名词。

例如：what i want is a happy life

what is difficult to understand id the noun ……

lz参考。

我不太明白这是什么结构，为什么有主谓还是名词短语呢，请指教，谢谢！

meggie_xm

不好意思这几天忙着攻克阅读呢，所以没来。

what i want 实际上等于something that i want,something肯定不能是句子了，忘记了吗？

rexyuewu

以下是引用pangpangshin在2007-5-3 11:31:00的发言：

73. The British Admiralty and the War Office met in March 1892 to consider a possible Russian attempt to seize Constantinople and how they would have to act militarily to deal with them.

(A)  how they would have to act militarily to deal with them

(B)   how to deal with them if military action would be necessary

(C)  what would be necessary militarily for dealing with such an event

(D)  what military action would be necessary in order
     to deal with such an event

(E)   the necessity of what kind of military action in
     order to take for dealing with it

 

答案为D

 

请问大家a possible Russian attempt to seize Constantinople and what military action would be necessary in order
          to deal with such an event

 

这不是名词和句子的并列么?这似乎不符合并列的习惯啊?

 

请指教!

 

这个你多做作就会知道了,很多时候尤其是难题,更在乎的是句意的平衡,而非形势上的平行

狠明确, deal with的宾语应该是it,指代俄国人的企图,所以AB错

C也错,因为在陈述句中的问句应该用陈述语气,所以次序要换成D那个样子

D,次序是对的,后面的部分也暂时看不出问题

E,狠明显的一个错误在于action后面应该是复数吧,另外你自己仔细读读那个后半句怎么都不通啊

另外what=one that,你想下如果问你  what would be necessary  military action in order
     to deal with such an event 你怎么回答?肯定是回答"XX军事行动"

那么consider后的并列成分就是2快,1考虑"俄国人可能的企图",2考虑"军事行动",难道这2个部分你还不觉得平行么?

pangpangshin

谢谢细心的答复 明白了