[求助]AA 47和144（新题）

dreadpower

47 地方报纸的商业版：
cumquat咖啡店的拥有者最近做出了一个出色的商业决定：搬迁到新地址。从事实可见，咖啡店会很快在那里庆祝它的两周年店庆。而且这项业务看来在原址上不能获得成功。因为咖啡店搬迁后，3家不同的商家：一个日光浴沙龙，一个古董店，一个宠物婚嫁店就占据了它原来的地址。

       我不是很明白作者这句话：“。因为咖啡店搬迁后，3家不同的商家：一个日光浴沙龙，一个古董店，一个宠物婚嫁店就占据了它原来的地址。”要表达什么意思？？？
      我只能写出来因为两周年店庆就说是成功错，

   144 the following appeared in a memorandum from the development director of the largo piano company.
“the largo piano company has long been known for producing carefully handcrafted, expensive pianos used by leading concert pianists. during the past few years, however, our revenues have declined, whereas those of the allegro musical instrument company increased after allegro introduced a line of inexpensive digital pianos. in order to increase largo’s sales and in fact outsell allegro, we should introduce a line of digital pianos in a variety of price ranges. our digital pianos would be likely to find instant acceptance with customers since they would be associated with the prestigious largo name.”
discuss how well reasoned . . . etc.
        这题我感觉逻辑关系牵扯在一起，不好表达，请牛人指教这题怎么写，谢谢

        另外，11月考，AA148-153不需要准备吧！

dreadpower

刚才忘了说一句，有个逻辑错误叫什么post hoc 什么什么的，那是什么意思啊？？

Taurus

以下是引用dreadpower在2003-11-7 19:17:00的发言：
刚才忘了说一句，有个逻辑错误叫什么post hoc 什么什么的，那是什么意思啊？？

后发生者即为结果。。

vrylwj

以下是引用dreadpower在2003-11-7 19:13:00的发言：
47 地方报纸的商业版：
cumquat咖啡店的拥有者最近做出了一个出色的商业决定：搬迁到新地址。从事实可见，咖啡店会很快在那里庆祝它的两周年店庆。而且这项业务看来在原址上不能获得成功。因为咖啡店搬迁后，3家不同的商家：一个日光浴沙龙，一个古董店，一个宠物婚嫁店就占据了它原来的地址。

        我不是很明白作者这句话：“。因为咖啡店搬迁后，3家不同的商家：一个日光浴沙龙，一个古董店，一个宠物婚嫁店就占据了它原来的地址。”要表达什么意思？？？
       我只能写出来因为两周年店庆就说是成功错，

  

最好看看英文原题，印象中是说，这三家相继在原址的位置上，(因为经营不好，所以搬迁的)。所以这样犯了没有可比性的fallacy~~
一方面不同行业之间没有可比性，
二者，时间不同也没有可比性。以前的失败 可能和其它原因有关。

vrylwj

144 the following appeared in a memorandum from the development director of the largo piano company.
“the largo piano company has long been known for producing carefully handcrafted, expensive pianos used by leading concert pianists. during the past few years, however, our revenues have declined, whereas those of the allegro musical instrument company increased after allegro introduced a line of inexpensive digital pianos. in order to increase largo’s sales and in fact outsell allegro, we should introduce a line of digital pianos in a variety of price ranges. our digital pianos would be likely to find instant acceptance with customers since they would be associated with the prestigious largo name.”
discuss how well reasoned . . . etc.
        这题我感觉逻辑关系牵扯在一起，不好表达，请牛人指教这题怎么写，谢谢

我感觉argument 是比较好写了,比如这题：

1.一看到during past year, 就可以断定有fallacy，过去现在的可比性。有assupmtion.
2.一看到和另一个公司allergo musical 出现，fallacy...公司之间的可比性，revenue 升降是否和题目所说的原因有关。
3. line of inexpensive digital pianos 和a line of digital pianos in a variety of price ranges 不等同
4.结论论据不足，无法推出.find instant acceptance since they would be associated with the prestigious largo name.

vrylwj

以下是引用dreadpower在2003-11-7 19:13:00的发言：
        另外，11月考，AA148-153不需要准备吧！

感觉准备的两三个月的机经题目即可

vrylwj

T 我步你后尘 ~~

vrylwj

踏着你的脚步走 ~~

(为什么现在贴子不能修改了呢？)

Taurus

V咪加油！~

对呀，T也在纳闷，有两天了，不能编辑。。

vrylwj

为什么啊~~~

不能写错啊 ~~