请教

Ibelive

请问有一道题说:价格的上涨导致了发行量的下降

我说是gratuitous assumption

可看的范文说是causality

这两个有什么区别啊

谢谢

pumpkin

太笼统了吧。。。哪个题目呢？

Ibelive

Newspaper A declines in circulation when lower-price newspaper B starts. So if A lower its price, its circulation will increase.

I don't know what is the difference between gratuitous assumption and the causality fallacy.


Sorry. I can't type Chinese now. There is something wrong with my laptop.

Cantaloupe

gratuitous assumption: It means the assumption itself is not convicing or not sufficiently proved, so that it can't be used to support the argument.

Causality means the "error in cause-and-effect". the reason is not match with the argument.

The former means the assumption itself, while the later one refer to the relationship.

Ibelive

thanks. U r so nice

Ibelive

那么, 那道作文题目,说200学生去抗议,1200没去.然后就assmue 说1200学生支持.

可以说是gratuitous assumption吗?

我看的范文说是a  fallacy of appeal ignore.

这是什么啊