大全733 还是关于平行 (885 补充材料91)

yzlinlin

733.    The distribution of mass within the core of the Earth, like the mantle that surrounds the core, has been deduced from the orbital behavior of the Earth and the motions of satellites controlled by the gravity of the Earth.
(A) the mantle that surrounds the core
(B) that within the mantle surrounding the core
(C) that of the mantle surrounding the core
(D) the mantle the core surrounds
(E) the distribution of mass within the mantle that surrounds the core

答案B。我曾选C，而且直到现在，我的第一反应往往还是C。

The distribution of mass within the core of the Earth
that of the mantle surrounding the core

觉得对称得很完美。到底我的考虑错在哪儿呢？

[此贴子已经被作者于2003-11-1 3:36:30编辑过]

mjiehu

within... , like within...
the distribution of mass within the core of the Earth
the distribution of mass within the mantle surrounding the core

C .
the distribution of mass within the core of the Earth
the distribution of the mantle sourrounding the core

yzlinlin

唉，经mjiehu 这么一还原，的确B的对称比C的更完美。

只是，在考试中如何摆脱先入为主，如何又快又准地找到正确答案？这大概就是需要下苦功修炼的地方了。
谢谢。

sparks

who can help to tell me why not select E, does it more perfect?

Avantasia

E中的the distribution of mass不符合能省就省的原则, 其次, 这里用分词更好, 定语从句表示一次性的感觉, 这里用分词修饰表示并不是一次性的事实.

sparks

thanks a lot

howardwang

选B的话，that应该是指代The distribution of mass ，这样指代可以吗？

那位nn可以讲讲。前两天一个GWD的题也是类似情况。

谢谢！

ustchero

我的理解：C选项中的that可以指代the distribution 也可以指代 the core,指代模糊，而B选项就没有这个问题

赞同Avantasia的省略原则，gmat里分词要优于从句做修饰成分。

dingxiang

如何判断B的还原为:

within... , like within...
the distribution of mass within the core of the Earth
that (the distribution of mass) within the mantle surrounding the core

就是因为B里面有一个共同的元素within, 所以that指代的就是within前面的所有成分?

lichabrend

up