讨论下LONGMAN的几个阅读题

joelyeah

第一道是指代题：MINI TEST 5的第七题

“…….The acute schizophrenic, unlike the simple schizophrenic, shows a sudden onset of the diease rather than a slow progression from one stage of it to the other.……”

The word it in paragraph 7 refers to

A. the diease

B. a slow progression

C. one stage

D.the other

这题答案选A，可是我觉得B也可以说得通啊？？大家觉得如何？？？

第二题：（READING POST-TEST）

"However, many experiments indicate that more than sight is involved. Some fish school quite well in the dark or in the murky water where visibility is extremely limited. This indicates that senses over than eyesight must be involved in enabling the schooling behavior."

the word This in paragrph 3 refers to the ability of fish to

A see well in dark water

B stay in school when they cannot see well

C swim in water where the visibility is low

D use their sight to stay in schools

答案选C，可我觉得是B

山衔落日

句子里已经写了“a slow progression from one stage of it”，这个it怎么能还是“a slow progression”呢？

第二个问题有点难度，主要是对“ Some fish school quite well in the dark or in the murky water where visibility is extremely limited.”的理解，或者说怎么找出一个正确的此句的改写。要注意这句话的谓语动词，是school，school做为名词有鱼群的意思，这里却是动词，意思是“成群结对地游”，所以C答案地swim要比B答案地stay要好，“where the visibility is low”也比B答案更加接近原句。

yinzheng66

第2题，

this 指代的就是前面的一句话

楼主再仔细读一遍句子，句子中没有提到B选项中的内容--stay in school

C 选项就是对那句话的改写，所以正确

如果选项内容包含文中没有提到的信息，肯定是错的！

joelyeah

以下是引用山衔落日在2006-11-17 14:35:00的发言：
句子里已经写了“a slow progression from one stage of it”，这个it怎么能还是“a slow progression”呢？

第二个问题有点难度，主要是对“ Some fish school quite well in the dark or in the murky water where visibility is extremely limited.”的理解，或者说怎么找出一个正确的此句的改写。要注意这句话的谓语动词，是school，school做为名词有鱼群的意思，这里却是动词，意思是“成群结对地游”，所以C答案地swim要比B答案地stay要好，“where the visibility is low”也比B答案更加接近原句。

可能是我理解的偏差吧，school在那句话中是动词指成群的游我看题是理解了，但是我觉得不对就不对在此，因为我觉得这句话强调的是鱼school的能力，也就是说在视力有限的情况下仍能结成结成群游的能力，而C中的swim则泛了点，只是指“游”，怎么游却没指出，所以我觉得C也不是很好，毕竟看不见时鱼肯定还是能游的啊，就像盲人能走路一样，但是看不见时那么多鱼还是能SCHOOL，我觉得这才是原文强调的意思，所以我当时才选B，大家怎么看待呢？？