到此为止了，请大家尊重我的意见，不要再跟了。(已请版主锁定）

tonychu1975

 

Dear Captain_Ma,

 Although I cannot fully digest your complex point here, however, some personal opinions I would like to share with you.

 1.      Admission to the MBA program is based on academy performance, GMAT scores, essays, recommendations, background and panel interview. The process is selective and produces one of the best-qualified groups of MBA students in the CKGSB. Probably, your “indirect rejection” is very common!

2.      Frankly, I feel you are not fit in with MBA program in terms of people characteristics or people personality. A mature MBA student will not post “angers”- complaints in the public, in contrast, a mature MBA student will find out one alternative way to solve the issue, say, to communicate with MBA program director in-depth.

 3.      Finally, Captain_Ma, a piece of advise to you! Please summarize your past application process, do a brainstorming to analyze your strengths and weaknesses in order to get offer from any other business school in the future.

 

PS: a good website to test your personality

  http://similarminds.com/big5.html

 Good Luck!

 Tony

albertwl

其实楼主最不能接受的是自己因为人招满为由被拒“今天早上给我电话说是今年人已经招满了，让我明年”，其他人却还有机会“下午我找了个朋友打电话去长江，自称GMAT660，得到的答复是只要在6号前完成网上注册就可以安排面试”，楼主觉得人招满只是个幌子，背后还有真正的原因。

sinoyuan

长江MBA今年的招生差不多接近结束，“可以安排面试”未必意味着“可以拿到OFFER”，这是个常识问题。

sinoyuan

刚刚跟长江招办联系，咨询关于06年和07年入学申请的问题，得到如下答复：

2006年的入学人数已经招满，11月6日前提交申请材料的申请人可以进入2006年度候补面试名单。

列入候补面试名单的申请人也许有机会（但不保证）参加本年度的候补面试（是否增加候补面试取决于已经录取的人员中有没有或有多少人申请延迟入学）。

2007年入学的第一轮面试从12月初开始，在11月底前提交的申请材料都会在12月初开始初步评估并择优邀请参加面试。

希望申请人07年入学的同学尽早申请。

MLG

以下是引用albertwl在2006-11-2 9:47:00的发言：
其实楼主最不能接受的是自己因为人招满为由被拒“今天早上给我电话说是今年人已经招满了，让我明年”，其他人却还有机会“下午我找了个朋友打电话去长江，自称GMAT660，得到的答复是只要在6号前完成网上注册就可以安排面试”，楼主觉得人招满只是个幌子，背后还有真正的原因。

这也没有什么不正常,全球的MBA都讲究班级的多样化. IT背景的人招多了,也许金融背景的人还有机会.男生招多了,女生也许还有机会.国内学生招多了, 国际学生也许还有机会.

青海的河峰

是啊,也许楼主会被片段的集合气着了. 这样的讨论方式也算展示了楼主的部分特质哈.

Background is what you did. You may show what you will do.

楼主何须生气嘛,以你这么优秀的背景,再努力一下GMAT考个780,估计全球的商学院该任你选了

yahoogoogle

If your experience is true, no need to apply the schools here. I think only Harvard is suitable for you. I strongly believe that you are just too good to be accepted by them. Take it easy!

yahoogoogle

But I really do not believe your words at all. I know the person you mentioned. What I am treated is totally different. That's also the main reason I had thought just apply CEIBS and now I decide to apply both CEIBS and CK.

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-11-2 11:56:53编辑过]

josephhan001

以下是引用captain_ma在2006-11-2 0:14:00的发言：

回楼上不明白：

1、本人从未说过gmat与口语有关，请阁下不要急于归纳。我再次提出申请也是与该招生人员多次沟通过的，包括我未考G前。之所以重新提出申请涉及到很多原因，恕我无法详述。

2、玩笑的内容不是这个，不过与这句话也就是前后的关系，所以阁下可以设想一下当时谈话的气氛是友好的，按正常思维来说应该不会让人很生气。  某天聊天时开了个很小的玩笑（当时我觉得大家已经很熟了，还提出让他来我这里招生，我请他吃饭）--阁下标红的，请注意“还”字！这里面有逻辑关系。

最后感谢阁下的关注。不过我不是来这里论战的，只是寻求帮助的。

你自己发了这个帖子，想讨个说法，想请这里的TX们帮助你。

帮助你的前提应该是：你是有合理的理由得到帮助的人。

在没有另一方当事人提供相关信息的情况下，判断你是否有合理的理由就只能基于你提供的信息（客观部分），而不是任何主观判断。（如果你考过GMAT，应该知道这个逻辑。）

如果因为你自己没有提供足够充分的信息，而造成别人判断有误。

你认为是你自己的原因还是别人的原因呢？

carlzhou

以下是引用tonychu1975在2006-11-2 9:41:00的发言：
 

Dear Captain_Ma,

 Although I cannot fully digest your complex point here, however, some personal opinions I would like to share with you.

 1.      Admission to the MBA program is based on academy performance, GMAT scores, essays, recommendations, background and panel interview. The process is selective and produces one of the best-qualified groups of MBA students in the CKGSB. Probably, your “indirect rejection” is very common!

2.      Frankly, I feel you are not fit in with MBA program in terms of people characteristics or people personality. A mature MBA student will not post “angers”- complaints in the public, in contrast, a mature MBA student will find out one alternative way to solve the issue, say, to communicate with MBA program director in-depth.

 3.      Finally, Captain_Ma, a piece of advise to you! Please summarize your past application process, do a brainstorming to analyze your strengths and weaknesses in order to get offer from any other business school in the future.

 

PS: a good website to test your personality

  http://similarminds.com/big5.html

 Good Luck!

 Tony

agree !