OG-56 解释没写，讨论也没有涉及

allen0018

    

56.
Architects and stonemasons, huge palace and temple clusters were built by
the Maya without benefit of the wheel or animal transport.

    

(A)  huge
palace and temple clusters were built by the Maya without benefit of the wheel
or animal transport

    

(B)   without
the benefits of animal transport or the wheel, huge palace and temple clusters
were built by the Maya

    

(C)  the
Maya built huge palace and temple clusters without the benefit of animal
transport or the wheel

    

(D) 
there were built, without the benefit of the wheel
            or animal transport,
            ？？？huge palace and temple
            clusters
by the Maya

    

(E)  
were the Maya who, without the benefit of the
            wheel or animal transport,
            ？？？built huge palace
            and temple clusters

画线部分是不是引起修饰不确定，夹心？？？ 大家能说说夹心的简单情况吗

谢谢大家

liquid_84

allen

例子没一时没找到，我觉得

D中的without the benefit of the wheel
            or animal transport,

没有修饰对象的

E的修饰是可以的，但它改变了原文的成分E中把Architects and stonemasons做主语了。

而原文是同位语

xjlv128

without ...应该紧放在主语后面，逻辑上修饰maya,

so, A is right

xjlv128

我觉得ＯＧ偏向：　如果夹心，应该修饰前面的，如果逻辑意思上不是修饰前面的，那么就错．

大家觉得呢？

littledou

As for the squinted modifier, please refer to OG 256E (I am not sure because I have no OG at hand now, please search for "squint" at OG)

Sorry, I can't input Chinese. I am still working on install the Chinese input method on my daughter's toy - the edubuntu Linux. I promised to get some games for her after my exam.

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-8-17 21:15:23编辑过]

allen0018

呵呵，little dou 大哥应该适当的引导小孩上CD ，这样人生才会完整

allen0018

由此可见，分词短语修饰前边，修饰的是前边句子的主语！！！！（至少ets这么认为的，以后这么理解就可以了）
介词短语也一样