请教GWD17-Q12没有讨论连接

lapotino

1.这里的in并不是与except连用，而是in the domains of...

而except与except for表达的意思是不一样，这点要看准。

2.如果去掉but就缺少转折意思。

except与except for什么区别阿？

wtylys

在这题目里面其实并不是区别except与except for
except与exceptfor的用法区别:



1)Except后排除的内容与主语往往是同一类的,而except for后所排除的内容与主语往往不是同一类的。例如,试比较:



All the buildings are excellent except this one.



All the buildings are excellent except for their location或者All the buildings are excellent except that the place on which the buidings are built is notgood.



这里用except for是说得过去的

其实D错误是因为，D中是excepting，是动词ing的形式，那么逻辑主语是language, 这里是不符合逻辑的
如果excepting，做介词的意思讲，词典这样解释
USAGE: The use of excepting is considered by many people to be acceptable only after not, only, always, or without. Elsewhere except is preferred: every country agreed to the proposal except (not excepting) Spain; he was well again except for (not excepting) a slight pain in his chest.



所以需要用except做介词，选C

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-2-14 21:11:59编辑过]

-- by 会员 celiachen (2009/2/14 21:08:00)

顶！！！！！！

owencjk

受教了

07102020131

在这题目里面其实并不是区别except与except for
except与exceptfor的用法区别:



1)Except后排除的内容与主语往往是同一类的,而except for后所排除的内容与主语往往不是同一类的。例如,试比较:



All the buildings are excellent except this one.



All the buildings are excellent except for their location或者All the buildings are excellent except that the place on which the buidings are built is notgood.



这里用except for是说得过去的

其实D错误是因为，D中是excepting，是动词ing的形式，那么逻辑主语是language, 这里是不符合逻辑的
如果excepting，做介词的意思讲，词典这样解释
USAGE: The use of excepting is considered by many people to be acceptable only after not, only, always, or without. Elsewhere except is preferred: every country agreed to the proposal except (not excepting) Spain; he was well again except for (not excepting) a slight pain in his chest.



所以需要用except做介词，选C

[此贴子已经被作者于2009-2-14 21:11:59编辑过]

-- by 会员 celiachen (2009/2/14 21:08:00)

感谢~~~~~

AHOLA

celiachen 发表于 2009-2-14 21:08
在这题目里面其实并不是区别except与except forexcept与exceptfor的用法区别: 1)Except后排除的内容与主语 ...

谢谢！！讲的很清楚，还有拓展的内容，谢谢