885 SEC A-11

hawkinsxie

C中as后的补出，因为是have动词，可以省略。如果是实义动词，则必须补出！

从这个理由来看，C无明显错误。

B中，share和same词组结构、语义重复；且对heritage而言，很难想象一个share的概念。

share means have sth. in common

share the common idea，share a cake等等。

doudouwin

以下是引用hawkinsxie在2006-5-1 10:09:00的发言：

C中as后的补出，因为是have动词，可以省略。如果是实义动词，则必须补出！

从这个理由来看，C无明显错误。

B中，share和same词组结构、语义重复；且对heritage而言，很难想象一个share的概念。

share means have sth. in common

share the common idea，share a cake等等。

同意

xteng

Here is a relatively formal document. "Discussion Paper 34 (1994) - Review of the Adoption of Children Act 1965 (NSW)"

9.17 Rather than approach ethnic heritage on the assumption that children must be placed with families who have precisely the same ethnic heritage as the child, perhaps the issue could be dealt with by identifying the reasons why children should experience continuity in their ethnic upbringing and then use these reasons as a placement guide.

definitely C is right. but I do not know why B is wrong.

洛拉

支持B，C选项的as后面应该加do吧？有谁能比较确定地讲讲啊？

洛拉

在语法区问的题经常很长时间都没人理睬？真奇怪，也许大家都明白只有我一个人不明白了

dreamhope

感觉这个句子侧重于southeast和 northeast在某一方面的比较，have the same..as..可以体现出两个事物的比较，

而share ..with则不能，用not share with暗含着northeasterner可能有不同的ethnic heritage，也可能没有ethnic heritage.

个人看法，不足请指正  

xiaowan

以下是引用nyc_cfa在2005-8-14 0:21:00的发言：

google出来的肯定有很多口语化的东西，不能算数吧。

我也认为as后面应该补出助动词，所以当初我也选了B。但是发现有好几道题都不按规则办事了。

主语，谓语助动词都有不按规则省得。像底下这个凭什么就省了阿。

OG149，

Last year, land values in most parts of the pinelands rose almost so fast, and in some parts even faster than what they did outside the pinelands.

a) so fast, and in some parts even faster than what they did

b) so fast, and in some parts even faster than, those

c) as fast, and in some parts even faster than, those

d) as fast as, and in some parts even faster than, those

e) as fast as, and in some parts even faster than what they did

所以考试的时候灵活一点了只能。

语法的复习就是这样，不同时期一定可以发现不同问题，一个月后重看这道当初的错题，the same....as的用法一定是个考点，而B的确不好，可是觉得算不上是大问题，至少与C的比较对象差异而言，省略是有章可循的，上面这题因为没有宾语所以those后面省略谓语不会有歧异，可the same..as明显比较对象出了差错，重新翻出这题，希望大家再次讨论！！

riverquiet

up

ustchero

我选的是E,好像没人选这个，请教各位E错在哪里？！

tonyfool

觉得是B。先排除A,D,E

C后面需要补助动词，因为这是主谓宾结构，没有助动词会认为是宾语在比较，下面用og 19说明

19.   In addition to having more protein than wheat
does, the protein in rice is higher quality than that in wheat, with
more of the amino acids essential to the human diet.
    

(A)
the protein in rice is higher quality than that in

    

(B)
rice has protein of higher quality than that in

    

(C)
the protein in rice is higher in quality than it is in

    

(D)
rice protein is higher in quality than it is in（B）

    

(E)
rice has a protein higher in quality than

OG "Choice E needs either that in or does after wheat to make
a complete and logical comparison." E如果加了that就是宾语比较，不需要助动词，如果是wheat做主语比较需要助动词。

这道题也是相似的，A has B。比较主语需要加助动词