请教高手885-B-6

gemj

6.    The 19th-century proponents of the school of thought known as mechanism held that life process are not the products of some mysterious life force, but are the same chemical and physical processes that operate in inorganic systems, which is still a subject of debate between biologists today.
(A) systems, which is still a subject of debate between
(B) systems, which are still debated between
(C) systems still debated among
(D) systems, a theory still debated by
(E) systems, a theory still debated between

答案：D
问题：如果将E中的between改为among，E能不能选？

gemj

请指教

givemeahome

OG里有好几道-ed + by，认为action agent更明确的；但如改成among，也见过，清高人指教那个更优

remeo

以下是引用givemeahome在2003-10-1 12:07:00的发言：
OG里有好几道-ed + by，认为action agent更明确的；但如改成among，也见过，清高人指教那个更优

我也认为是by要优于among，因为如果是用by，表达的意思是正是这些biologists  而没有别人在 debate ，而如果用 among 的话，表达的意思是 debate的人 有很多，biologists   只是其中一部分，扩大了原文的范围，这也是常考点之一。

个人意见，仅供参考/

sbbi

by is better than amony here, because it follows debated. if it is something like "a theory still having a lot of debates", among may be better. any opinions?

gemj

谢谢各位XDJM。

thornbirdcfa

用between的话，应该跟上and　表在什么之间吧？否则句意不通．我觉得可以用among. 　　　各位有意见吗？

[此贴子已经被作者于2004-1-6 3:41:23编辑过]

stella131

请教为什么e错啊～

好想也有debate between这个搭配的吧

当当84

谁可以帮我分析一下这个句子的结构啊,因为我看不出,为什么要用,a theory ....

谢谢！！

dori0214

以下是引用stella131在2004-7-18 16:02:00的发言：

请教为什么e错啊～

好想也有debate between这个搭配的吧

难道between一定要用在两个相关事物之间的？