September JJ 切磋 (2)

sbbi

那29到底啥结论呀?

昨天趟床上有想了想,如果represent的主语是one feet and four teeth,那如果有下边的一个选项是不是好些:
4') the discovery in nk of one feet and four teeth, which represent four species of animals like cats, indicates that the animal survives …
这里"one feet and four teeth, which represent four species of animals like cats,"是长宾后置,因而"in nk"的位置也就合理了.再根据GEMJ"瘸子里面拔将军"原则,3)反而是最合理的啦.尽管承认这点对我很痛苦...

Look at OG CR:
97.Leaders of a miners’ union on strike against Coalco are contemplating additional measures to pressure the company to accept the union’s contract proposal. The union leaders are considering as their principal new tactic a consumer boycott against Gasco gas stations, which are owned by Energy Incorporated, the same corporation
that owns Coalco.

以下是引用gemj在2003-9-23 13:57:00的发言：
我看29好象可以结案了。现在大侠们再讨论一下SBBI的下面这个问题吧。

braveMBA

OG CR 97居然用了consider as,....哈哈，这在SC里可是杀头治罪呀。

35. 选2。因为NOT ONLY，BUT ALSO遵循严格的对称，象BOTH AND。

givemeahome

29. 1) the discovery of one feet and four teeth in nk, representing four species of animals
     like cats, indicates that the animal survives …
2) the discovery of one feet and four teeth in  nk, which represents four species of
animals like cats, indicates that the animal survives …
3) the discovery in nk of one feet and four teeth, representing four species of animals
like cats, indicates that the animal survives …

representing 修饰one feet and four teeth 说不通， 这句话说的式，发现NK这个动物有one feet and four teeth, NK represents，（这个NK象猫科里的四种，）这显示这个动物存活于。。。
故3不对

My answer 2)

littlebluesk

totally agree with givemeahome!

braveMBA

以下是引用givemeahome在2003-9-24 1:44:00的发言：
29. 1) the discovery of one feet and four teeth in nk, representing four species of animals
      like cats, indicates that the animal survives …
2) the discovery of one feet and four teeth in  nk, which represents four species of
animals like cats, indicates that the animal survives …
3) the discovery in nk of one feet and four teeth, representing four species of animals
like cats, indicates that the animal survives …

representing 修饰one feet and four teeth 说不通， 这句话说的式，发现NK这个动物有one feet and four teeth, NK represents，（这个NK象猫科里的四种，）这显示这个动物存活于。。。
故3不对

My answer 2)

nk更合理地理解为NK--地名。否则in是有问题的。

xianwharton

, representing four species of animals  like cats,请注意前面的逗号，这样的结构是可以做定语的可参见og 205，所以A 中的representing 不可能定nk，也不可能做状语，因为牵扯到逻辑主语的问题，而C中representing很好的修饰了one feet and four teeth ，正是这一条腿和四颗牙代表了四种像猫的动物，注意one feet and four teeth并不一定就在一个动物身上。所以我认为C对。
34A，help to 和 help do 优选help do,虽然help to 也对
35先不管倒不倒装，not only 和 but also 后的形式一定要对称，此题可参见og 166

xianwharton

以下是引用sbbi在2003-9-22 21:13:00的发言：
885 补充题
181. Dr. Sayre’s lecture recounted several little-known episodes in the relations between nations that illustrates what is wrong with alliances and treaties that do not have popular support.
(A) relations between nations that illustrates
(B) relation of one nation with another that illustrates
(C) relations between nations that illustrate
(D) relation of one nation with another and illustrate
(E) relations of nations that illustrates
why  choose B?I think C.what do you think?
Answer B. why is not B ambiguious?

sbbi

Why 优选help do?

以下是引用xianwharton在2003-9-24 10:54:00的发言：
34A，help to 和 help do 优选help do,虽然help to 也对

sbbi

和我不谋而合. However, in OG 205, acting is to qualify peaks, rather than mountain range. some subtle difference....

205. The peaks of a mountain range, acting like rocks in a streambed, produce ripples in the air flowing over them; the resulting flow pattern, with crests and troughs that remain stationary although the air that forms them is moving rapidly, are known as "standing waves."

以下是引用xianwharton在2003-9-24 10:54:00的发言：
, representing four species of animals  like cats,请注意前面的逗号，这样的结构是可以做定语的可参见og 205，所以A 中的representing 不可能定nk，也不可能做状语，因为牵扯到逻辑主语的问题，而C中representing很好的修饰了one feet and four teeth ，正是这一条腿和四颗牙代表了四种像猫的动物，注意one feet and four teeth并不一定就在一个动物身上。所以我认为C对。

gemj

以下是引用braveMBA在2003-9-24 0:43:00的发言：
OG CR 97居然用了consider as,....哈哈，这在SC里可是杀头治罪呀。

35. 选2。因为NOT ONLY，BUT ALSO遵循严格的对称，象BOTH AND。

SBBI的例子中ETS虽然犯了晕，但不影响SBBI的想法，因为是长宾语后置的情况是很常见的。