一道不明白的题

xianwharton

Bob Wiber became Sidney Bechet's student and protege when he was
nineteen and ,for a few yeears in the 1940's,came as close to being
a carbon copy of the jazz virtuoso in performance as anyone has ever
come.A as anyone has ever come
B as anyone ever had been
C as anyone ever had done
D that anyone ever did
E that anyone ever came
答案是A可我觉得A 的时态不对吧？请各位指教。

[此贴子已经被作者于2003-9-21 9:35:50编辑过]

xianwharton

up

braveMBA

你找一下以前讨论过此题。

braveMBA

这题前些天有人问过，但问的主要不是时态问题，而是COME，BEEN，DONE的选择。
Bob Wiber became Sidney Bechet's student and protege when he was nineteen and ,for a few yeears in the 1940's,came as close to being a carbon copy of the jazz virtuoso in performance as anyone has ever come.
A as anyone has ever come
B as anyone ever had been
C as anyone ever had done
D that anyone ever did
E that anyone ever came
1、COME的选择
came as close to being a carbon copy of the jazz virtuoso in performance as anyone has ever come [close to being a carbon copy of the jazz virtuoso in performance ]
省略了划线的内容。在比较结构中，如果实意动词出现在比较从句中一定要比DO或其他的助动词代替要明确，因此优先考虑。
这时候实际上只剩下A、E，E明显不符合as...as的比较结构。

2、时态问题
我觉得这里似乎都可以讲通，一般过去时，过去完成时，现在完成时（可以理解为到现在为止曾经COME的人）。但是，似乎ever had的语序不是很好的方式，但我不认为它绝对错误，只是不优。

3、优选原则
一定是优选，不是PERFECT，例如这题就是，在时态问题上就是有摇摆。这个原则在XDF老题里更明显，在现在的OG中似乎ETS在尽量避免这个问题，向它理解的PERFECT努力，但也不是100%。

纯个人观点，仅供参考。

xianwharton

you are very nice.