[原创]谈谈加拿大的MBA

she3652003

以下是引用TANTAOGZLJ在2006-2-11 3:47:00的发言：

赞美LZ的话就不重复了，下面说几点个人意见，给各位提供思路。

1，不同意LZ的排名，本人意思是：R＝I＝Q，第一档（各有所长）， 其他都是第二档

2，要看FT， BS等排名，不要只看排名，要深入地看是根据什么标准来排的。

3，好的商学院的标准：好老师，好学生，好工作，这些都是在网上可以查得到的，如果你都看完教授学生简历，招聘公司的情况，哪家好，心里就有数了。

4，最后补充一点，Queen's的就业要看毕业后六个月的，这样比较公平。

为什么说Q的就业要看毕业后六个月的？

还有据Q的一个学生讲，到现在中国学生没有一个找到工作的，是不是这样呢？Q应该5月份就毕业了吧？

网上关于Q的介绍非常有限，这从一定程度上说明了Q的校友网比较小吧？

没有冒犯Q的意思，我对Q一直很感兴趣，也已经申请，想多了解情况。谢谢！

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-2-11 11:47:11编辑过]

she3652003

以下是引用TANTAOGZLJ在2006-2-11 8:12:00的发言：

Q整个商学院的校友（包括商业本科，AMBA，EMBA，MBAst，PHD等），全加起来校友圈并不小，好象有19000（数字可能不准）。

具我所知，MBA学生和EMBA,等其他的学生一般是很少有network往来的，这不仅仅是queens的情况，而是普遍的现象。而且queens的学生也是这么认为的。

参考http://forum.chasedream.com/dispbbs.asp?boardid=13&replyid=1297960&id=134575&page=2&skin=0&Star=4

希望能多有TANTAOGZLJ一样的GG多出来介绍Q的情况。谢谢TANTAOGZLJ GG了

TANTAOGZLJ

回答she3652003:

呵呵，不客气。

1,为什么说Q的就业要看毕业后六个月的?

因为Q是连上12个月的课，没有4个月的暑假。毕业6个月后基本上是所有的学生都努力找了一把。

2，到现在中国学生没有一个找到工作的，是不是这样呢？Q应该5月份就毕业了吧？

在中国读大学的中国人中，好象是这样。不过其中一部分人还没开始找，因为学习太忙了。从现在到5月是最后一节，应该是大家开始重点找工作的时候了。

其实换个角度看可能更清楚，在Q，谁都不缺面试机会。来校面试公司数量比学生总数还多。(作为学校，也只能送你到这一步了）

3，网上关于Q的介绍非常有限，这从一定程度上说明了Q的校友网比较小吧？

必须承认：中国校友很少，但不等于Q的校友网小，在加拿大商界，Q的校友网是挺强的。

4，具我所知，MBA学生和EMBA,等其他的学生一般是很少有network往来的，这不仅仅是queens的情况，而是普遍的现象。而且queens的学生也是这么认为的。

现在讨论的是读商学院的价值问题，而立杆见影地对你有帮助的是老前辈们。通过校友网联系，老校友们一般都买帐。如果要寻求帮助，当然是你主动去拉关系啦！

所谓校友网的价值，就是指你所能拉上关系的数量和质量，不用管平时往来，也不用管他是哪国人。

最后，Q的女生奇少，对she3652003来说是利好，祝你成功！

[此贴子已经被作者于2006-2-11 14:47:16编辑过]

ESeraph

thanks.

扬凡

以下是引用TANTAOGZLJ在2006-2-11 8:12:00的发言：

其实真正和Rotman, Ivey的MBA竞争生源的可能是AMBA（只招有商业本科背景的），不过它采用了part-time,这是聪明的做法。

请问AMBA指的是什么呢?哪些学校有这个专业?

在google上只搜到说是MBA的一种认证,这个好象不是文中提到的AMBA吧.

DavidBCA

For your comments on McGill, I do not agree. How did you know the employment rate in McGill MBA? How did you know the empolyment rate of Chinese MBA graduate from McGill? I feel a little strange about your data. I admit that the place in which McGill is located, Montreal, is not a very good place for Non-French speaker. But, that does not mean that there is no chance for McGill MBA students, especially Chinese students. I graduated from McGill MBA program. Many Chinese students, especially with FInance concentration, found a decent job in Canada, such as Royal Bank of Canada, CIBC, National Railway, Generale Society, Paribas Bank, Paris National Bank, etc.

I doubt whether you lived in Montreal before. Everyone knows that there are a lot of big Canadian & American companies in Montreal. In fact, many big USA & Canadian companies have two headquarters in Canada--Montreal and Toronto. So still there are a lot of chances for Chinese McGill MBA students. And also, some McGill MBA students come to Toronto. Finally, they got a very decent job in Toronto. Why? Just because of the Brand Name--McGill. In Canada, Everyone knows McGill better than other schools because McGill has the best ranking in Canada for the longest time. In US Wall street, the Investment-Bankers know only one Canadian School, McGill.

As to the tuition McGill charge, the tuition difference in McGill is not because of McGill itself. If you stayed in Montreal, you should have known that the tuition difference in Quebec Province where Montreal is is set up by Quebec Government. Quebec Government wants to attract more and more immigrants, so they set up a low tuition for Quebec immigrants and Canadian residents in Quebec.

hereme

对加拿大ＭＢＡ分析超过英国金融时报

我是二流子人才（在读书方面），我去ＹＯＲＫ．

blahblah

多谢DavidBCA的介绍，你是McGill的MBA，你可能对蒙城更了解，在蒙城生活方便吗？我指天气和法语。此外，要去McGill还需要一个魁北克的单独学习许可吧，怎么申请呢？多谢了。

TANTAOGZLJ

以下是引用扬凡在2006-2-19 4:22:00的发言：

请问AMBA指的是什么呢?哪些学校有这个专业?

在google上只搜到说是MBA的一种认证,这个好象不是文中提到的AMBA吧.

Queen's Accelerated MBA for Business Graduates is designed specifically for people with an undergraduate degree in business, and at least two years of relevant work experience - people who have come to realize that a world-class MBA degree will broaden their opportunities and help them fast-track their career. It is an intensive and innovative program that enables you to earn a Queen's MBA in just 12 months, while continuing to work at your current job.

DavidBCA

If you plan to study in McGill MBA, you need to apply for CSQ (Certificate Selection Quebec) to get into Quebec Province of Canada. Canadian Embassy and Quebec Government (CSQ website) will tell you how to apply for it. It is easy to get it. You only need to show your money and your admission offer letter.

Montreal is a nice city. In summer, it is not as hot as China. And, in winter, it is cold. But, everywhere there is a good heating system in Montreal. So, you do not need to worry about it. As for French, people speak both French and English. laceName w:st="on">McGilllaceName> laceType w:st="on">UniversitylaceType> is an English-teaching university. So, you do not need to learn French for your MBA study. But, McGill MBA program offers a French course to help you find job in Montreal and Canada. So you can learn French through your MBA program.

I do not know whether you noticed that McGill business school has a new brand name – Desautels Faculty of Management. Because of the donation from Mr. Desautels, McGill MBA program has become one of the richest MBA programs in the world. So, I believe that McGill MBA program will have a better ranking in the global MBA education in the future, even though it has already achieved a good reputation in Canada and world.