[讨论]OG11th-99

seasnow

99.Just as reading Samuel Pepys’s diary gives a student a sense of the seventeenth century—of its texture and psyche—so Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer inside turn-of-the-century Vienna.

(A) so Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer

(B) so listening to Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer

(C) so the guileless child narrator of Jane Freed takes the operagoer

(D) listening to Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer

(E) Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer to her opera

选D？平行结构。

lukrenee

偶选D~~

v521

agree

woodstone6

just as的用法（来自LZM）

a do sth.,just as b do

just as b do sth., so a do

just as b do, so too....

and with the parallelism, so B is correct.

Evelyn2005

99.Just as reading Samuel Pepys’s diary gives a student a sense of the seventeenth century—of its texture and psyche—so Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer inside turn-of-the-century Vienna.>>

(A) so Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer>>

(B) so listening to Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer>>

(C) so the guileless child narrator of Jane Freed takes the operagoer>>

(D) listening to Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer>>

(E) Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer to her opera

我觉得应该选E。只有E是独立clause, 选其他选项的话，这个句子就没有主句了。英语里有个单词形容这种错误的，一时想不起来了。而且两个破折号连用相当于两个逗号连用，也就是说原题可以改写为：Just as reading Samuel Pepys’s diary gives a student a sense of the seventeenth century, of its texture and psyche, so Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer inside turn-of-the-century Vienna.不知道这样的话大家是不是觉得句子结构更清晰一些？

v521

2005mm，

选d也有主句阿，just as....,...,xxx takes xxx.后面的不是主句么，而且跟前面的reading xxx还平行。

如果选e的话，逻辑意思就不对了吧，原文是：正如读xxx给学生一种17世纪的感觉，听xxx也把xxx带到了xxx

wycg

B

大全里的题.

ppbb

Who knows the offical answer for this one? Thanks!

wycg

以下是引用ppbb在2006-2-3 9:15:00的发言：

Who knows the offical answer for this one? Thanks!

有OG11的朋友帮忙看一下.

谢谢!!!

bluevironika

og11中正确答案是b。

just as b do sth., so a do这个是官方解释~~