GWD 21-6 求助

windspeaker

以下是引用felix_zheng在2005-11-21 23:39:00的发言：

我发现读懂句子逻辑意思对选择太重要了.

A,B,C中紧接COUSINS候紧接一堆形容词,才会构成歧义的.

恩　

没弄懂逻辑意思

yale_qiu

OG中似乎是规定代词不可跨过分号进行指代的

一下子找不到了

joejo9

還是不明白D爲什麽不對，Or with XXX的結構是否有問題？具體有什麽問題？although後面不能加adj麽？

gonghao

以下是引用paveway在2005-11-19 17:05:00的发言：

E - they are often green and striped, or have plenty of bumps and bruises, but they are

the 2 "they" both refer to "Heirloom tomatoes" without any ambiguity and confusion.

different opinion

they could both refer to "tomatoes" and "cousins" I think

although there is "their" at the first clause, but in E, they still have some ambiguous meaning

罗马青年

理解句子本身的含义重要

chanx_ceci

up

tangzimo

以下是引用carolhide在2005-12-10 11:31:00的发言：
我没有看出这里有平行，E中的they明确了指代对象不是从逻辑上推出的，而是从第一句中的their中推出的，句子中一套代词只能指代同一个对象。

说得精辟！

lichabrend

up

lichabrend

up

StellaWJ

个人觉的这题选A

HT, grown from seeds saved from the previous year, only look less appetizing than their round and red supermarket cousins, often green and striped, or have plenty of bumps and bruises, but are more flavorful.

首先,从逻辑意思上A比较合理. HT looks.....or have plenty of  b&b, 这里less appetizing 和b&b 都是形容HT比较差,相比较g&s的cousins.  相比而言觉得E的意思很奇怪

其次,从语法上动词look 和have可以并列,often green and striped修饰cousins做状语还是补语的随便......然后说but, 其实BUT 也不一定后加句子,这句but后的主语应该还是HT.当主语相同的时候,后一个主语可以省略,当然如果谓语也相同的话也可以连省略一起省(高中语法).E的话语法上的错误其实更明显些,比如they,觉的这个THEY的存在让这句话变的很烂

不过BUT的省略确定是不是被G认可的书面语,or也显的不怎么严谨...........吃力>_____<b

[此贴子已经被作者于2008-7-27 16:41:10编辑过]