求助贴：phd申请如何尽量避开自己的短板？

Lisa.S

Chen-XiangRu 发表于 2024-6-9 02:25
到底是谁傲慢呢xs，要不是你这惊为天人的qs理论我还不想回复呢，你这些申请了也不会有什么结果的以前cd上 ...

你说得对啊陈相如，赶紧做研究去吧，别老过来刷帖子了，注册没多久在线时间倒不短。我也要忙了。我不喜欢吵架，很无脑。

Lisa.S

Chen-XiangRu 发表于 2024-6-9 02:25
到底是谁傲慢呢xs，要不是你这惊为天人的qs理论我还不想回复呢，你这些申请了也不会有什么结果的以前cd上 ...

哇难得见到如此情绪化的浓人phd了，快接着骂我！&追问下xhs是个啥...可以备着哪天emo了看

raccoon_paw

Lisa.S 发表于 2024-6-9 02:14
**** 该帖被屏蔽 ****

题主这种直接挂个人信息的做法非常没品。首先，陈同学说话是难听，但是你本人的一些回复确实是缺少对于申请PHD的一些基本概念。其次，如果只是因为说话难听就要被人肉了挂出来，那chilling effect最后的结果就是没人会帮助你，甚至影响到帮助其他人。最后，可能CD上的这个陈同学可能并不是你挂出来的那个陈同学，不一定同名同姓就是同一个人。

BTW Iowa State 的IS挺好的，现在IS又很火，这没啥好黑的。

古天乐

申请PHD强调QS排名是一件很显得自己没有好好做过什么功课的事情
NO BODY IN ACADEMIA GIVE A DAMN SHIT ABOUT QS RANKING
有必要上这个链接


https://www.youtube.com/shorts/KsAswZ1Ejhw

Tripleg

古天乐 发表于 2024-6-27 10:15
申请PHD强调QS排名是一件很显得自己没有好好做过什么功课的事情
NO BODY IN ACADEMIA GIVE A DAMN SHIT AB ...

Indeed, even UTD Top 100 Business School Research Ranking is marginally relevant to PhD applicants, not to mention QS or USNews university rankings.

古天乐

Tripleg 发表于 2024-6-27 21:32
Indeed, even UTD Top 100 Business School Research Ranking is marginally relevant to PhD applicant ...

I generally don't understand why Chinese are so obsessed with rankings.
in the latest US News World Ranking
Dartmouth ranks 300+
UTD ranks 400+
That is ridiculous

Tripleg

古天乐 发表于 2024-7-4 05:07
I generally don't understand why Chinese are so obsessed with rankings.
in the latest US News Worl ...

Humans are obsessed with rankings by nature.

By the way, the ranking information here regarding Dartmouth and UTD needs to be factchecked.

Lisa.S

raccoon_paw 发表于 2024-6-9 11:18
题主这种直接挂个人信息的做法非常没品。首先，陈同学说话是难听，但是你本人的一些回复确实是缺少对于申 ...

我没有黑，如果都了解我还来问干嘛，申博士不就是万里长征总得有第一步么。而且你自己点进去这个人的主页，他的回复基本都是这种非常刻薄的语言。挂信息是因为他本来就是公开的，都贴主页里面了，我复制一下就成我的问题了？如果现实里遇到这么尖酸刻薄的博士你会怎么想？在美国读博士就能说话这么难听是吧。他之前回复的贴子都没博主搭理。这种人非得来个人怼一下他才知道什么叫礼貌。别人都尖酸到鼻子眼儿上了还搁这儿装绅士呢？he deserved it！（还有我就是这么个人，对好人说好话对差人说差话，我也是非常希望论坛不要再出现说话如此刻薄的人，也会影响别人提问的热情不是，其他随你怎么说吧。不过你能这么跟帖我相信你是个善良柔软的人，祝你生活开心~）

Lisa.S

古天乐 发表于 2024-6-27 10:15
申请PHD强调QS排名是一件很显得自己没有好好做过什么功课的事情
NO BODY IN ACADEMIA GIVE A DAMN SHIT AB ...

谢谢您的推荐，我觉得非常有用，我会仔细考虑一下的！

Lisa.S

古天乐 发表于 2024-7-4 05:07
I generally don't understand why Chinese are so obsessed with rankings.
in the latest US News Worl ...

You are very correct in this question, which means that your education system has instilled in you dialectical thinking, which is a very good mode of thinking. But in China, as you question, meritocracy basically carries through the learning life of a Chinese child, including the whole of East Asia (Japan and Korea are not immune to this meritocracy trap). I hope that I can see a more egalitarian social evaluation through this question, because I have always felt that meritocracy is not a good education model, and I hope to see real education, an education system that breaks people's prejudices can make students think better. That's one of the reasons why I brought up the points of disagreement when I asked this question. Thank you very much for your suggestions and responses, I will consider them carefully.