OG18 SC689题求助

Gillian-guo

689. Unlike the nests of leaf cutters and most other ants, situated underground or in pieces of wood, raider ants make a portable nest by entwining their long legs to form “curtains” of ants that hang from logs or boulders, providing protection for the queen and the colony larvae and pupae.


(A)  the nests of leaf cutters and most other ants,


(B)  the nests of leaf cutters and most other ants, which are


(C)  leaf cutters and most other ants, whose nests are


(D)  leaf cutters and most other ants in having nests


(E)  those of leaf cutters and most other ants with nests


求助D选项，我看OG官方解释是D选项的话，整个句子 suggests that it is raider ants, not leaf cutters and most other ants, that have nests situated underground or in pieces of wood; however, the rest of the sentence indicates that in fact raider ants’ nests are not situated in such locations。我不太明白为啥就变成这个意思了呢？为什么这样改变in having nests就是修饰raider ants了呢？虚心求教啊~~~

andizza

in表示了unlike在什么地方？

Sharon_LAU

D选项里面的in having是 noun modifier就近修饰leaf cutters and most other ants这个整体吧...不如C选项好; 给我的感觉就是限定性修饰和非限定修饰区别; 如果是D，感觉是缩小范围了; C就不是;

Gillian-guo

andizza 发表于 2018-1-9 19:42
in表示了unlike在什么地方？

我咋看都没理解，因为D选项raider ants前面才有逗号，那unlike一整个分句都在说leaf cutters and most other ants。。。是在没理解

yougushizi

unlike并列，unlike后面接的是和raider ants并列的结构，就是某ants，只有c符合。d的话unlike ... in having nests...很awkward，如果having做定语从句不应该有in。

Gillian-guo

Sharon_LAU 发表于 2018-1-9 21:23
D选项里面的in having是 noun modifier就近修饰leaf cutters and most other ants这个整体吧...不如C选项好 ...

谢谢NN，我也是这么理解的，可是看OG解释D选项就和我自己解释的不一样，就不理解官方对于D选项的解释，看不懂。。。

Gillian-guo

yougushizi 发表于 2018-1-9 23:14
unlike并列，unlike后面接的是和raider ants并列的结构，就是某ants，只有c符合。d的话unlike ... in havin ...

谢谢NN！能否帮我解释一下OG对于D选项的解释是啥意思呢？OG的解释我放在上面了，就是看不懂和我的解释不一样，谢谢~

弗雷泽631

怕是D项在In的前面漏了个逗号。如果是comma+in的话才解释得通答案里面的prepositional phrase，如果是修饰raider ants的话充其量就是个后置。

C肯定比D用得好。从优原则。都不需要纠结。

Gillian-guo

弗雷泽631 发表于 2018-1-11 19:43
怕是D项在In的前面漏了个逗号。如果是comma+in的话才解释得通答案里面的prepositional phrase，如果是修饰r ...

嗯嗯，也觉得不要太纠结了，题能做对就行，谢谢~