Adam Smith和YOUNG PEOPLE那道题

RoxieHeart

In 1776 Adam Smith wrote that it is young people who have “the contempt of risk and the presumptuous hope of success” needed to found new businesses.

A.        who have
B.        with
C.        having
D.        who are those with
E.        who are the ones to have

RoxieHeart

正确是A但是B错在哪里？？

RoxieHeart

这是我在beatthegmat上面找到的
Let's break down what is wrong with each of the incorrect answers:

In 1776 Adam Smith wrote that it is young people who have “the contempt of risk and the presumptuous hope of success” needed to found new businesses.

A.        who have
This one is correct because it's telling us young people have this particular quality without being overly wordy.

B.        with
By changing it to "with," we now have a sentence fragment. If you read it aloud, you'll find yourself wanting to know more information to complete the thought. Young people with these qualities do....what??
但是我的问题是，确实B如果是强调句型缺少 who
应该是it is young people who
但是为什么不能理解为这些年轻人需要做found这件事
是不是因为时态不对如果是这样的话就应该是it is young people with.... need to found

你是认真的吗

em...needed是过去分词作定语哦，假如是过去式的话，with后面不能加句子，错误的。

Smith wrote that it is young people with blahblahblah，假如选B的话，it没有指代的对象，错误，原因应该出在这里

MikaT

觉得原句表达的是【强调】young people有怎样的特质。
B改变了原句的意思，而且好像句子没说完一样--“it is sb. with sth. 然后呢”