做了几遍还是没有彻底弄懂的语法题 求大神帮忙

tiankbh

71_？

Untilrecently, the Inuit people led a nomadic existence, sheltering in
igloos, the ice-block domes that are peculiarto north-central Canada,
and in structures made of stones, bones,driftwood, and skins.

A. Until recently, the Inuit people led anomadic existence, sheltering
B. During recent times, the Inuit people lead a nomadic existence,
sheltering.
C. In the times that are recent, the Inuit people led anomadic exis-
tence, sheltered.             两个谓语动词❌
D.Up until recently, the Inuit people, leading a nomadic exis-
tence, have sheltered.
E. Until recent times, leading a nomadic existence, theInuit people
were sheltered.

   

不明白为什么选a 觉得应该用完成时才对

为什么e不对呢？d也没看出来错在哪

还麻烦各位大神帮忙分析一下这个题 越详细越好呀

ai559031

D. up 跟until 是redundancy, 直接用until就好; 時態問題： recently雖然是最近,但是仍然是過去式,時間點在最近的過去,不應該用現在完成式

E. 有雙向修飾問題, 另外改變了句子階層, 原句的 led a nomadic existence在E被改成了插入句, 句子階層被改變

RichardVeritas

E
Until recent times 不如 Until recently.
the Inuit people were sheltered 在句意上有问题。他们被sheltered，被谁sheltered呢？另外被sheltered和 leading a nomadic existence 两部分在句意逻辑上不合理，是什么关系？
A 则清楚。 the Inuit people led anomadic existence 是主干，讲他们如何生活。sheltering in... 修饰描写一些背景细节。

tiankbh

ai559031 发表于 2017-9-2 22:33
D. up 跟until 是redundancy, 直接用until就好; 時態問題： recently雖然是最近,但是仍然是過去式,時間點在 ...

请问您说的双向修饰 是指夹心修饰嘛？

ai559031

tiankbh 发表于 2017-9-4 17:12
请问您说的双向修饰 是指夹心修饰嘛？

對對對 哈哈