关于去年9月JJ里的一道题

tomwalkson

2.Just like the background in art history needed by an archaeologist in order to evaluate finds of ancient art, the nautical archaeologist needs specialized knowledge of the history and theory of ship design in order to understand shipwrecks.

A.  Just like the background in art history needed by an archaeologist in order to evaluate finds of ancient art, the

B.  Just as an archaeologist who needs a background in art history to evaluate finds of ancient art, a

C. Just as an archaeologist needs a background in art history to evaluate find of ancient art, so a

D. Like the archaeologist who evaluates finds of ancient art and requires a background in art history, so the

E. As evaluating finds of ancient art requires an archaeologist who has a background in art history, so the

参考答案为E, 但我们选C

以上是原贴的一部分。我总觉得相比之下似乎B更好一些。这个as不是在archaeologist和nautical archaeologist 之间作比较吗？如果换成C，so似乎也多余啊？请各位批评指教了。

howardwang

我觉得明显是C啊，怎么会是E.

找不出选E的理由。我坚信c.

tomwalkson

哦，不好意思，我是说B选项，能否指教B的不妥之处？多谢了先

v22

我也觉得C好于E呀

B的JUST AS 没有主语啊，fragment

z520m

B很显然是不对的，这里的Just as an archaeologist who needs就是不正确的，ets如果要表示的话，应该表示为 an archaeologist, who....。在og中，限制性定语从句表示限定的意思，B的 an archaeologist who needs表示还有an archaeologist who does not need。并且即使这样表达是正确的，B也不很不正确的，as 后面要根句子，要有谓语，可是B中的as 后面只跟了一个名词和定语从句，不存在谓语。

综上所述，B错。