885 Section C-16

cz

16.   The decisions of John Marshall, the fourth chief justice, have had a greater influence than any chief justice in history.

(A) than any chief justice in history

(B) historically than any other chief justice

(C) than have those of any chief justice in history

(D) in history as any other chief justice has had

(E) than those of any other chief justice in history

正确为E。 有点迷惑的是选项C， 就是多了“have”。 为什么不保留助动词呢？

andrew_li

The decisions (those of any chief justice) can not "have" here. Another mistake in C is the use of any, which includes John Marshall himself.

howardwang

以下是引用andrew_li在2005-8-8 3:05:00的发言：
The decisions (those of any chief justice) can not "have" here. Another mistake in C is the use of any, which includes John Marshall himself.

Another mistake in C is the use of any, which includes John Marshall himself.有道理的；

但是，The decisions (those of any chief justice) can not "have" here.不明白为什么？请斑竹解释一下。谢谢。

因为我认为，C在any后加了other,一定可以作为正确选项的。

adii

以下是引用andrew_li在2005-8-8 3:05:00的发言：
The decisions (those of any chief justice) can not "have" here. Another mistake in C is the use of any, which includes John Marshall himself.

同意关于any应该是any other的说法

我觉得应该与those have done 而不是those have 比较

andrew_li

以下是引用howardwang在2005-8-8 8:46:00的发言：

Another mistake in C is the use of any, which includes John Marshall himself.有道理的；

但是，The decisions (those of any chief justice) can not "have" here.不明白为什么？请斑竹解释一下。谢谢。

因为我认为，C在any后加了other,一定可以作为正确选项的。

Oops, my mistake. I thought the main subject was John Marshall.

konson

3x