AAA19集思广益中参加讨论提高自己惠及他人

judydongxueni

A19. The following appeared in a memo from the president of Pampered Pooch Spas, a chain of luxury dog-grooming businesses.
“Over 70 percent of the current households in the town of Philazoa have pets, many new families are moving into Philazoa, and kennels in the area continue to report brisk sales of puppies. Furthermore, the average family income in Philazoa is 50 percent higher than the national average, and a local store reports record-high sales of the most expensive brands of dog foods. With so many devoted pet owners and such liberal spending to take good care of those pets, Philazoa will be a profitable location for a new Pampered Pooch Spa — a dog-grooming business that offers premium care at higher than average prices.”
1The market is highly competitive since a lot of companies have provided this kind of product.
2fallacious analogy
3The profit can not be guaranteed because this kind of luxury dog-grooming product may still can not be afforded by the residents although they have a above-average income.

enila_c

4.There is no evidence indicate that the families having higher income have the pets(or the most families having higher income are included in the 70% households having pets).

katie83

以下是引用judydongxueni在2005-6-18 23:42:00的发言：

A19. The following appeared in a memo from the president of Pampered Pooch Spas, a chain of luxury dog-grooming businesses.
“Over 70 percent of the current households in the town of Philazoa have pets, many new families are moving into Philazoa, and kennels in the area continue to report brisk sales of puppies. Furthermore, the average family income in Philazoa is 50 percent higher than the national average, and a local store reports record-high sales of the most expensive brands of dog foods. With so many devoted pet owners and such liberal spending to take good care of those pets, Philazoa will be a profitable location for a new Pampered Pooch Spa — a dog-grooming business that offers premium care at higher than average prices.”
1The market is highly competitive since a lot of companies have provided this kind of product.
2fallacious analogy
3The profit can not be guaranteed because this kind of luxury dog-grooming product may still can not be afforded by the residents although they have a above-average income.

错误类比在哪里呢?

cournot

1)among the 70 percent of the current households with pets,most households have income below the average family income in Philazoa-they are unlikely to afford the service;

2)kennels in the area continue to report brisk sales of puppies-most of puppies are bought by the people in the neighboring towns other than  hilazoa;

3)highly competitive maket in Philazoa-already many companies set new stores there.

genes

以下是引用judydongxueni在2005-6-18 23:42:00的发言：

A19. The following appeared in a memo from the president of Pampered Pooch Spas, a chain of luxury dog-grooming businesses.
“Over 70 percent of the current households in the town of Philazoa have pets, many new families are moving into Philazoa, and kennels in the area continue to report brisk sales of puppies. Furthermore, the average family income in Philazoa is 50 percent higher than the national average, and a local store reports record-high sales of the most expensive brands of dog foods. With so many devoted pet owners and such liberal spending to take good care of those pets, Philazoa will be a profitable location for a new Pampered Pooch Spa — a dog-grooming business that offers premium care at higher than average prices.”
1The market is highly competitive since a lot of companies have provided this kind of product.
2fallacious analogy
3The profit can not be guaranteed because this kind of luxury dog-grooming product may still can not be afforded by the residents although they have a above-average income.

1. 70 percent may be an indicator of saturated market and the new dwellers may not be the potential consumers

2. people with high income are not equally likely to patronize Pampered Pooch Spas for dog-grooming service, although they have spent a lot on luxury dog foods.

3. Kennel's increasing sales of dogs may result from households in other area.

4. devoted pet owners are inclined to take care of the dog by themselves rather than send it to a dog-grooming company.

(我有疑问的是这里dog-grooming business倒底是个什么服务阿？)