GWD 10-32

Febby1984

以下是引用jamesyeah在2005-9-21 20:48:00的发言：

我倒是觉得应该选择C,省略主语才是

open to discuss

如果选c, inhibit和comes from平行，主语都为benefits，that is, benefits inhibit...不符合逻辑的~

mymengming

注意这里的C如果理解为also前省略了that are和inhibit前也省也不对。因为后面那个明显是不能省的。

mayce

that 到底指代谁？

huhai

以下是引用Avantasia在2005-6-22 15:22:00的发言：

应该是.

我的感觉是GWD里面很多题目, 当最后二选一的时候, 能避开代词就避开代词.

严重支持。实际上，如果从句意来看，THAT必须指代那个什么物质，绝对不能指代BENEFITS（如果选E就变成这样了）。因为抑制什么什么的一定是物质。

huhai

以下是引用LunarLin在2005-9-21 23:29:00的发言：

D. come from antioxidants-compounds that are also found in beta carotene, vitamin E, and vitamin C and （that）

E.  come from antioxidants-（compounds also found in beta carotene, vitamin E, and vitamin C）, and they

E正确，因为破折号相当于逗号的功能，对前面的内容进行补充说明，E中的they指代中心词antixidants。D中的that没法指代复数，而且前面没有逗号分开，后面就不应该出现主谓结构的句子，所以肯定错！

D中的that没法指代复数？？？这是严重错误的概念，后果很严重！---我个人认为，如果我不对欢迎大家批判。

lucyzl517

这道题选错的人大概都是题没读清楚,包括我

开始选C,仔细读题后发现C中inhibit既可以和found并列也可以和come并列,所以会让reader产生误会

而D中用compounds that...,and that...就非常清楚了

E中they指代不清

GawainERIC

以下是引用lucyzl517在2006-10-19 7:29:00的发言：

这道题选错的人大概都是题没读清楚,包括我

开始选C,仔细读题后发现C中inhibit既可以和found并列也可以和come并列,所以会让reader产生误会

而D中用compounds that...,and that...就非常清楚了

E中they指代不清

C中的inhibit和found怎么可能并列呢，一个是谓语动词，一个是分词，而且inhibit前面有and，就已经避免了于found并列。。。

为什么大家都不讨论C呢，我就觉得C语法正确，并且比D简洁

superwangche

以下是引用GawainERIC在2007-8-1 22:33:00的发言：

C中的inhibit和found怎么可能并列呢，一个是谓语动词，一个是分词，而且inhibit前面有and，就已经避免了于found并列。。。

为什么大家都不讨论C呢，我就觉得C语法正确，并且比D简洁

我刚开始也误选了c, 不过仔细再想确实有问题，逻辑错误。

mirinno

看到GMAT club上歪果仁見解，觉得很有道理，和大家分享下：
What is wrong with C?

When fully expanded C will read:

Most of the purported health benefits of tea come from antioxidants—compounds also found in beta carotene, vitamin E, and vitamin C, and inhibit the formation of plaque along the body’s blood vessels.

The subject of the first part is - most (of the health benefits)- and the verb is – come -. By default, the subject of the second part is -( most ) of the health benefits -and its verb – Inhibit.

You can see the distortion of the meaning that it is the purported health benefits that inhibit plaque rather then the anti-oxidants. This is why C is not the right choice.

In E, the pronoun they may refer to the health benefits since subject rightly takes priority over any other noun that is placed nearer than the subject, per se.