more likely than 与as likely as

yunwujiexiao

【求助】prep08 SC 212 more than句型和as likely as可以互换吗
http://forum.chasedream.com/foru ... amp;fromuid=1110039

According to a survey of graduating medical students conducted by the Association of American Medical Colleges, minority graduates are nearly four times more likely than are other graduates in planning to practice in socioeconomically deprived areas.

• Aminority graduates are nearly four times more likely than are other graduates in planning to practice  分析A选项
• Bminority graduates are nearly four times more likely than other graduates who plan on practicing  分析B选项
• Cminority graduates are nearly four times as likely as other graduates to plan on practicing  分析C选项
• Dit is nearly four times more likely that minority graduates rather than other graduates will plan to practice  分析D选项
• Eit is nearly four times as likely for minority graduates than other graduates to plan to practice  分析E选项
  

求问 more likely than 和as likely as 能互换吗？比如原句有大四倍的意思吗,还是仅仅就是四倍。A与C 之间该怎么选？

86274619hua

看 be likely to do and plan on, 别管4倍还是5倍

86274619hua

86274619hua 发表于 2015-7-24 14:40
看 be likely to do and plan on, 别管4倍还是5倍

选c比较好，剩下d和e 肯定错

wolk8

就只看这个题目。。。个人感觉more likely than 和 4 times as likely as是没有任何差异的……这个不是这题考点感觉

首先DE不说了直接杀掉- -就看前三个选项，
A选项有个are，那are后面的成分是和谁平行呢？minority graduates是主语，那么和他平行的话不可以前面有个are，
B选项，那个who后面都修饰other graduates，那么，句子成分就残缺了……
C选项虽然用了as likely as，但是句意并没有改变（GMAT不会抠4倍5倍这种牛角尖的），比较对象也正好是minority graduates 和 other graduates，更改了A中的错误 are likely to do也符合搭配。

86274619hua

wolk8 发表于 2015-7-24 16:09
就只看这个题目。。。个人感觉more likely than 和 4 times as likely as是没有任何差异的……这个不是这题 ...

能帮我看下We have THREE TIMES AS MANY pears AS you 为什么as you后面不加do，have是及物的啊，不会造成歧义we have you 吗

wolk8

86274619hua 发表于 2015-7-24 16:31
能帮我看下We have THREE TIMES AS MANY pears AS you 为什么as you后面不加do，have是及物的啊，不会造 ...

这个我也不太清楚不过我感觉应该是要加do的吧。。。如果说没问题可能是逻辑上觉得we have you过于诡异已经不存在于他们的正常思维之中了吧……所以默认省略have

86274619hua

wolk8 发表于 2015-7-24 17:21
这个我也不太清楚不过我感觉应该是要加do的吧。。。如果说没问题可能是逻辑上觉得we have you过于诡异已 ...

你可以看我的帖子，在语法里，感觉不加helping verb绝对会出现歧义，可以说 i have more sth than (i have) you...可是og和曼哈顿都是直接用他than u （as ...as u）烦

wolk8

86274619hua 发表于 2015-7-24 17:54
你可以看我的帖子，在语法里，感觉不加helping verb绝对会出现歧义，可以说 i have more sth than (i hav ...

那就相信曼哈顿吧！大概他们认为这里没有歧义

yunwujiexiao

86274619hua 发表于 2015-7-24 14:40
看 be likely to do and plan on, 别管4倍还是5倍

受教但是 be likely to do 中间能加如 be likely (in planing) to do 吗？

86274619hua

这样句意就变了，原来in plaing 是两种人的状语，现在就成了单独修饰前面第一种情况。