香港理工会计PHD被录，有人了解吗？真的很不知所措。。。

IVOWELCH

i would choose poly for sure.

IVOWELCH

accounting phd基本不需要学什么宏观，除非那种比较变态的学校，而且微观宏观这些就是基础课，只要不拿c，对以后做研究根本没影响。

你忽略了很重要的一点，就是PolyU这四年的PHD的学习难度和压力和MSA完全不可比拟。
Accounting的PHD，高微高宏计量统计这些基础课和MSA那些by course的会计课完全不在一个难度层级上，会计研究和实务会计可不太一样，你做好沉浸在数学课中的准备了么~
再说就算目标是industry,你总要有paper才能毕业吧，读PHD的四年里你大部分时间都会纠结在怎么写paper怎么过qualify怎么毕业上，这对你以后进industry实在没什么帮助，有这个时间还不如去实习或者积累人脉~
总之，PHD可不是四年的MSA项目哦，另外商科PHD去industry的真的不多，而且大多是比较差劲的PHD，你可以去各院校的网站上看看历年的placement.

-- by 会员 zjq407 (2011/5/12 17:35:38)

IVOWELCH

呵呵,我觉着不比ob啥的高, 那么多烂校本科, 四大工作的老美,整的太难,他们智商也不够用阿.

sorry for that,我按照我们学校硕博的课程要求来推断了~macro确实不太需要，不过micro和econometrics的要求还是不低的吧~

-- by 会员 zjq407 (2011/5/12 22:36:51)

IVOWELCH

他们都是那么claim的, 大部分中国在读学生的econometrics水平其实都overqualify了.

你可以去各商学院的网站上看看会计PHD的course requirements,我还真没见到什么program不要求econometrics的

会计还要econometrics？？

-- by 会员 rxchang (2011/5/12 23:06:40)

-- by 会员 zjq407 (2011/5/13 10:57:19)

IVOWELCH

只要你知道微观在讲什么，会用上面的理论讲故事就行了，根本不需要很懂 。

micro-economics and econometrics are really the fundamental to accouting archival research.  I didn't realise this when I first entered into the programme. But as the more research i do, the more i realised more important these two are. If you are poor on these two, you just cannot publish !!

Chinese students are just very good at pure math. But u gotta know acc phd is not math phd. You really need to know how to apply "math" to the real research.

你可以去各商学院的网站上看看会计PHD的course requirements,我还真没见到什么program不要求econometrics的

会计还要econometrics？？

-- by 会员 rxchang (2011/5/12 23:06:40)

-- by 会员 zjq407 (2011/5/13 10:57:19)

-- by 会员 huiye (2011/6/11 23:13:07)

IVOWELCH

我说的很懂是明白里面的证明，自己也会去证明。理解是很容易的，书上把故事都讲好了，自己慢慢看，消化了就行了，阿猫阿狗都可以的 。

if u don't understand it, how can u use it ?? ^_^

just joking, i think micro gives a training about how to think of the rationale behind the research.  many arguments in acc archival papers just do not make an awuful lot of sense

只要你知道微观在讲什么，会用上面的理论讲故事就行了，根本不需要很懂 。

micro-economics and econometrics are really the fundamental to accouting archival research.  I didn't realise this when I first entered into the programme. But as the more research i do, the more i realised more important these two are. If you are poor on these two, you just cannot publish !!

Chinese students are just very good at pure math. But u gotta know acc phd is not math phd. You really need to know how to apply "math" to the real research.

你可以去各商学院的网站上看看会计PHD的course requirements,我还真没见到什么program不要求econometrics的

会计还要econometrics？？

-- by 会员 rxchang (2011/5/12 23:06:40)

-- by 会员 zjq407 (2011/5/13 10:57:19)

-- by 会员 huiye (2011/6/11 23:13:07)

-- by 会员 IVOWELCH (2011/6/11 23:31:34)

-- by 会员 huiye (2011/6/11 23:38:47)