OG 13 SC68题，对答案有疑义，请NN进来讨论一下！

rorkey

68. Outlining his strategy for nursing the troubled conglomerate back to health, the chief executive’s plans were announced on Wednesday for cutting the company’s huge debt by selling nearly $12 billion in assets over the next 18 months.
(A) executive’s plans were announced on Wednesday for cutting the company’s huge debt by selling nearly $12 billion in assets over the next 18 months.
(B) executive’s plans, which are to cut the company’s huge debt by selling nearly $12 billion in assets over the next 18 months, were announced on Wednesday
(C) executive’s plans for cutting the company’s huge debt by selling nearly $12 billion in assets over the next 18 months were announced on Wednesday.
(D) executive announced plans Wednesday to cut the company’s huge debt by selling nearly $12 billion in assets over the next 18 months.
(E)  executive announced plans Wednesday that are to cut the company’s huge debt by selling nearly $12 billion in assets over the next 18 months.


对这题的答案选D，我觉得还是有问题的。相比起来，我觉得E的问题更小。
答案D：announced plans to ....，这里，plan是一个名词，所以语意上后面的不定式并不是修饰plan这个名词，而是announce这个动词（manhattan里也说不定式是动词修饰语）。因此这里后面的不定式部分表示了announce的目的，而这个逻辑上肯定不对：announce plans的目的不是cut debt; cut debt靠announce也实现不了。所以这个逻辑上是不对的。即使这个to cut...也可以做名词修饰语，那既可以做名词修饰语修饰plans，也可以做动词修饰语announced，则也有ambigious的问题。

答案E：根据manhattan SC语法里的解释，对于一长串修饰语，that从句要比V-ing、不定式要来得直观，GMAT更偏向于选择that从句。而这里that直接修饰了plans，非常清晰，没有答案D的模糊，所以that are并不wordy。plans are to cut....这个也是合乎语法的。

所以觉得这题答案有争议，翻看论坛里，貌似没有对这里提出疑问的。

关于有答主说plan to do sth，那个是plan是动词，而这里plans是名词。所以不能直接套。

历史贴这里有点：
http://forum.chasedream.com/foru ... &highlight=sc68


请各位NN们看看是否同意我的说法？

alzn2765

我的理解是即使plans are to sell是正确的，但plan主动发出selling这个动作也是不合理的：
executive announced plans Wednesday that (are to cut the company’s huge debt by selling nearly $12 billion in assets over the next 18 months.)括号里的内容都是that的从句成分，that如果指代plans，则把that替换为plans，从句可以还原为plans are to cut the company’s huge debt by selling nearly $12 billion in assets over the next 18 months. plans to do sth我觉得还可以，但是plans作为selling的动作发出者就不符合逻辑了。这句话，如果想用定从的表达方式应该是这样的：
By selling nearly $12 billion in assets over the next 18 months, executive announced plans Wednesday that are to cut the company’s huge debt 这样至少可以消除selling的逻辑主语问题，但是语义又不好了，变成by doing成了announce的一个方式。


所以，还是D最好。

语法题排除的顺序应该是 语法错误--->表达形式错误--->语义（逻辑）错误
这题
第一步根据outline的逻辑主语判断ABC先死，没说的。
第二部看by doing 中doing的逻辑主语，排除E，选D。
总共就一个Decision Points：逻辑主语（或者动作的发出者），应该是一道秒选题。
说白了语法大部分考的就是谁发出的动作(who)，做什么了(what)，和怎么做的(how)。

kwyang

"(E)...,the words that are extraneous and also suggest that the plans themselves are doing the cutting and selling." From OG

slgbond

楼主是个语法王，sc只看语法会死人。ED没有语法错误，但语意上你不关注啊！plan to do 和 be to do语意不重复了吗，D简洁规避了此问题。og中还有at first ，begin to do。gwd里还有compare to sth compatably，不从语意上看，这些题，你都得抓瞎。看你被sc蹂躏得还不够

Classy17

rorkey 发表于 2015-11-16 23:04
The computer company has announced that it will purchase the color-printing division of a ri ...

这个没什么疑问吧
需要将来时 to make 和 will make 一下就能选出来的吧.

rorkey

Classy17 发表于 2015-11-16 13:44
我不知道NN们怎么想的 不过这确实是我的思路

      The computer company has announced that it will purchase the color-printing division of a rival company for $950 million, which is part of a deal that will make it the largest manufacturer in the office color-printing market.

      (A) million, which is part of a deal that will make
      (B) million, a part of a deal that makes
      (C) million, part of a deal making
      (D) million as a part of a deal to make
      (E) million as part of a deal that will make

对比一下这道题，CD里也有不少讨论。主要分析DE答案的异同

Classy17

rorkey 发表于 2015-11-16 10:50
这里to do修饰的是announced；而that are to修饰的是announced的宾语，不能这样简单的判断后者wordy吧？
两 ...

我不知道NN们怎么想的 不过这确实是我的思路

rorkey

Classy17 发表于 2015-11-15 13:29
1. announced...to do something...
2. announced...that are to do something... (wordy) X

这里to do修饰的是announced；而that are to修饰的是announced的宾语，不能这样简单的判断后者wordy吧？
两者的逻辑意思不一样。

Classy17

1. announced...to do something...
2. announced...that are to do something... (wordy) X

rorkey

没有大仙进来讨论啊，再顶一下，别沉咯。。。