全奖欧洲 还是小奖美国 大家请指教

chenpeiran83

今天刚收到的offer from Norwegian School of Management. 

两年 一年在挪威, 一年可能在 University of Bath, School of Management, Bath, UK,

The Mannheim Business School Mannheim, Germany
 

ESCP-EAP (European School of Management), Paris, France 

Nanyang Business School, Singapore

Tuition waive+Living expense+ 一年两次回国假期的往返机票(总价大约40万RMB)

钱真的不少. 那时候申请是因为是跟FUDAN共建的学校.... 面试的时候 老师说他们在欧洲是TOP的学校. 貌似是20th.

原来我是已经准备去University of Alabama了,它家也给了一点米. 而且签证已经办好了.

我的计划是拿个master degree in marketing以后 工作2.3年以后 如P&G, 然后去读MBA. 最后Consulting. 

去UA的话  最好的结果是留在美国工作2.3年. 不好的话,是回国工作2.3年.   去挪威的话,读完是一定要回国的,因为是拿了奖的.

哪个机会成本会比较大?..........迷惑中.

20多了,有点不太想花家里的钱了.  家里却说钱不是首要考虑的.  我现在知道什么叫"有钱能叫鬼推磨了", 我不是的话,也至少是"有钱能叫人动心了".

大家帮我看看,  对于我毕业以后两三年的工作机会 以及 MBA 学校的申请. 选择哪个学校更好一些.  谢了Sincerely

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-4-28 1:37:36编辑过]

mba3000

UA is not such a good school. The European school you mentioned is probably better but it seems that it is a joint program in Europe.

American South is very racist.

I would suggest that you try some Chinese schools such as CKGSB and CEIBS and try to get an opportunity to exchange to the top business schools such as UC Berkley, Darden or Duke. For example, with Darden, you can stay there from August to March for 7 months and it is a top business school.

I also believe many Chinese schools will dominate the two schools you are mentioning. Notice that the median salary from the top three Chinese business schools is around 300,000 RMB. In 4 or five years, RMB/dollar exchange rate is likely to be corrected and fall to 3. That means graduates from Chinese business schools should get about 100,000 USD as the median. Moreover, Chinese market is growing faster than US schools. 100,000 USD is much higher than either Alabama or Norweign is comparable to top 15 US business schools.

Have foresight!

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-4-28 4:04:01编辑过]

有勇有谋

二话不用说, 全奖欧洲!

水浒传中,阮小二有句名言: 俺这一腔热血,只卖与识货的.

给你全奖的那家,显然对你很欣赏. 去吧, you have nothing to lose.

chenpeiran83

以下是引用有勇有谋在2007-4-28 15:08:00的发言：

二话不用说, 全奖欧洲!

水浒传中,阮小二有句名言: 俺这一腔热血,只卖与识货的.

给你全奖的那家,显然对你很欣赏. 去吧, you have nothing to lose.

哇~~~这个讲的  实在让偶有点激动~呵呵  严重考虑你的建议

chenpeiran83

以下是引用mba3000在2007-4-28 3:04:00的发言：

UA is not such a good school. The European school you mentioned is probably better but it seems that it is a joint program in Europe.

American South is very racist.

I would suggest that you try some Chinese schools such as CKGSB and CEIBS and try to get an opportunity to exchange to the top business schools such as UC Berkley, Darden or Duke. For example, with Darden, you can stay there from August to March for 7 months and it is a top business school.

I also believe many Chinese schools will dominate the two schools you are mentioning. Notice that the median salary from the top three Chinese business schools is around 300,000 RMB. In 4 or five years, RMB/dollar exchange rate is likely to be corrected and fall to 3. That means graduates from Chinese business schools should get about 100,000 USD as the median. Moreover, Chinese market is growing faster than US schools. 100,000 USD is much higher than either Alabama or Norweign is comparable to top 15 US business schools.

Have foresight!

谢谢, 好logical的analysis........

DengZong

I choose to disagree. the logic is lousy.

I doubt this:

---

In 4 or five years, RMB/dollar exchange rate is likely to be corrected and fall to 3. That means graduates from Chinese business schools should get about 100,000 USD as the median.

DengZong

I also challenge that gentleman's logic on 'median salary': the median salary from the top three Chinese business schools is around 300,000 RMB.

----

Even though that statement might be true, SO WHAT?

For every MBA grduate,the pay package depends on his or her induvidual background, capabilities and soft skills.

It is illogical to assume, infer or conclude that, after MBA education from a certain b-school, everybody can get that kind of pay or higher.

As a matter of fact, for a centain number of persons, they may have to start from relatively lower payment no matter they go to Chinese or European or American business schools, no matter they have or haven't an MBA degree.

mba3000

with respect to the exchange rate, we will see. If you look at the purchasing power parity, I am not way off. Combined with the higher growth of China, it is my best estimate.

Certainly there is no guaranttee. I am only providing a best estimate. That is what we do when you have to make decisions with uncertainty. Managerial economics will tell you how to do that.

chenpeiran83

呵呵~~大家讨论挺热烈的~~