一道argument, 请大家帮忙找一下fallacy. Many thanks!

target111 · 发表于 2008-12-23 09:26:00

有一道argument题，请大家帮忙找一找fallacies. 我只能找到一条。

题目：Recent technological improvements in electronic mail will resolve existing corporate communication problems. Vast quantities of information about products, services, and market transactions as well as most basic business communications, can be electronically exchanged, quickly and at a relatively low cost.

我只想到hasty generalization. 其他的请大家提示。

rachelchen52 · 发表于 2008-12-23 10:15:00

这题让人感觉摸不到边际。。。我想了又想，想出了以下问题，不知道算不算：

1.Recent technological improvements in electronic mail will resolve existing corporate communication problems.

这个技术提高是在e-mail里的，但却解决了现存的公司所有内部沟通问题，这不可能，公司沟通问题有很多，不止邮件沟通，还会有电话沟通、上下级沟通什么的，邮件技术的提高只限于部分解决邮件沟通问题。

2.Vast quantities of information about products, services, and market transactions as well as most basic business communications, can be electronically exchanged, quickly and at a relatively low cost.

缺乏证据证明这个技术可以帮助exchange quickly

也没有证据提供说成本会下降，也可能这个提高的技术的使用将cost a Lot of money，引进技术的成本要大于以前沟通不利所损失的，如果这样，那cost就不会be lowered.

总觉得有点牵强，但我实在想不出了。。。

target111 · 发表于 2008-12-23 10:30:00

Thanks for the prompt answer! I thought the second sentence is an evidence (we do not argue with evidence). If it's part of conclusion, them this argument is based on nothing?

rachelchen52 · 发表于 2008-12-23 10:38:00

嗯，我觉得第二句没有证据证明，可以说this argument is based on nothing吧。但应该还有其他fallacies吧。。。我是想不出了。。。

一道argument, 请大家帮忙找一下fallacy. Many thanks!

一道argument, 请大家帮忙找一下fallacy. Many thanks!

所属分类: 下线版块

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()