last－10－4－16

G: The group of works exhibited in this year’s Metropolitan Art Show reveals a bias in favor of photographers. Equal numbers of photographers, sculptors, and painters submitted works that met the traditional criteria for the show, yet more photographs were exhibited than either sculptures or paintings. As you know, each artist was allowed to submit work in one medium only.

H: How could there have been bias? All submitted works that met the traditional criteria—and only those works—were exhibited in the show.

16(C).   If both G’s assertions and H’s assertion are true, which one of the following must also be true?

(A) More photographers than sculptors or painters submitted works to be considered for exhibition in the Metropolitan Art Show.

(B) All the works submitted for the Metropolitan Art Show met the traditional criteria for the show.

(C) The quality of photographs exhibited in the metropolitan Art Show was inferior to the quality of the sculptures or paintings exhibited.

(D) Some of the photographs submitted for the Metropolitan Art Show did not meet the traditional criteria for the show.（E）

(E) More works that met the traditional criteria for the Metropolitan Art Show were submitted by photographers than by sculptors or painters.

我选C

G 推理more photographs were exhibited than either sculptures or paintings----à bias in favor of photographers

H : All submitted works that met the traditional criteria---à no bias

如果这两个说法都成立，则：

C结论 photographs的质量稍逊色. 这样就解释了G 的bias. 又可以理解成虽然稍逊色，但也能通过criteria.所以解释了H 的no bias.

如果选E,就削弱了G的bias.--à是因为photographs上交的作品数量多，不是因为有歧视才展出更多photographers 的作品

但正确选项是E

C) could be true

Please notice that the question is a "must be true"

这里要的是和G 和H都一致的说法，所以要看他们的共同点，即, 他们都承认一个事实:more photograhs than other works, and all works meet the criteria. (他们只对是否有BIAS存异议)

E) 按照你的理解, 是有削弱G观点的趋势，但是和G的观点还是CONSISTENT的. PHOTOGRAPHERS上交的数量多，被多选， 还是有可能有BIAS,但 也可能没有

什么时候我也能有版主一样犀利的目光啊!

怎么你一说我就明白了.

自己做的时候就容易糊涂

原文说Equal numbers of photographers, sculptors, and painters submitted works that met the traditional criteria for the show

E说More works that met the traditional criteria for the Metropolitan Art Show were submitted by photographers than by sculptors or painters.

这不是矛盾么？