if / only if / if and only if 区分

玛莎丁丁 · 发表于 2012-7-24 22:05:34

"If the fruit is an apple, then Madison will eat it." or "Madison will eat the fruit if it is an apple." (equivalent to "Only if Madison will eat the fruit, is it an apple;" or "Madison will eat the fruit ← fruit is an apple")This states only that Madison will eat fruits that are apples. It does not, however, preclude the possibility that Madison might also have occasion to eat bananas. Maybe she will, maybe she will not—the sentence does not tell us. All we know for certain is that she will eat any and all apples that she happens upon. That the fruit is an apple is a sufficient condition for Madison to eat the fruit.

"Only if the fruit is an apple, will Madison eat it." or "Madison will eat the fruit only if it is an apple." (equivalent to "If Madison will eat the fruit, then it is an apple" or "Madison will eat the fruit → fruit is an apple")This states that the only fruit Madison will eat is an apple. It does not, however, preclude the possibility that Madison will refuse an apple if it is made available, in contrast with (1), which requires Madison to eat any available apple. In this case, that a given fruit is an apple is a necessary condition for Madison to be eating it. It is not a sufficient condition since Madison might not eat any and all apples she is given.

"If and only if the fruit is an apple will Madison eat it" or "Madison will eat the fruit if and only if it is an apple" or "Madison will eat the fruit ? fruit is an apple."This, however, makes it quite clear that Madison will eat all and only those fruits that are apple. She will not leave any such fruit uneaten, and she will not eat any other type of fruit. That a given fruit is apple is both a necessary and a sufficient condition for Madison to eat the fruit.

if / only if / if and only if 区分

所属分类: 法学院申请

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()