大家觉得在商学院phd program成功，哪些因素比较重要

dandanapple · 发表于 2010-2-4 23:51:59

could u rank the follwing factors according to their contribution to the sucess of a phd student? (measure of sucess：initial placement, research productivity)

A personal effort
B talent
C intuition
D program quality
E luck
F capability and connection of advisor
G advisor‘s willing to work closely with student
H academic and professional background before entering the phd program
I program reputation

大家踊跃灌水吧~

炒汇 · 发表于 2010-2-4 23:59:55

Talent>

ersonal Effort>Intuition>advisor's willing to work closely with student>F>D>H

sm1 · 发表于 2010-2-5 02:18:27

why no program reputation?

person effort > talent > program quality > supervisor quality

dandanapple · 发表于 2010-2-5 03:11:15

我把program reputation加上去~

program quality 是指program requirement(coursework，research) and peer quality？

why no program reputation?

person effort > talent > program quality > supervisor quality

-- by 会员 sm1 (2010/2/5 2:18:27)

darcie · 发表于 2010-2-5 03:22:28

advisor> program reputation(quality)>effort

fzxc613 · 发表于 2010-2-5 04:15:05

all matter

xiaopanghu · 发表于 2010-2-5 05:17:26

luck

yedeanboy · 发表于 2010-2-5 05:36:21

Luck>advisor>reputation

nothing else really matters.

xiaopanghu · 发表于 2010-2-5 05:53:56

所以攒人品还是王道阿

zirtek · 发表于 2010-2-5 12:57:14

首先这个效用函数不是线性的
如果你要去top school, 就必须要从top school出来，当然是指lz说得initial placement
但如果你去二流学校，那么program reputation就没那么重要：一流二流三流都有可能

其次这个效用函数不是连续的
有些条件符合即可，符合了之后，再好上去就没有意义
比如chicago有个说法：如果你的导师没有来我们学校的资格，我们就不会考虑你。
但是，如果你（的导师）在这条线之上，那么你的导师究竟是一般牛还是超级牛，对你找工作的直接影响就很小了

大家觉得在商学院phd program成功，哪些因素比较重要

所属分类: 商学院申请

正在浏览此版块的会员 ()

浏览过的版块