對PREP08有一道題的分析跟曼哈頓中文精簡版的解釋有疑問

miki_042

在PREP08有這樣一道題:

Whereas the honeybee’s stinger is heavily barbed and cannot be retracted from the skin, because the yellow jacket has a comparatively smooth stinger, it is therefore able to be pulled out and used again.

A.     because the yellow jacket has a comparatively smooth stinger, it is therefore able to be pulled out and used

B.     the comparative smoothness of the yellow jacket’s stinger allows them to pull it out and then can therefore use it

C.     the yellow jacket’s stinger is comparatively smooth, and can therefore be pulled out and used

D.     in comparison, the yellow jacket’s stinger is smooth, and thus able to be pulled out and used (C)

E.      in comparison, the yellow jacket has a smooth stinger, thus allowing it to be pulled out and used

它答案是選C..無疑這個答案是全部答案裡面最好的..但我看PREP之前看過曼哈頓中文精簡版..裡面有解釋說..and前面有逗號則and後面必有主語..
它給出這樣一個例子: Earl walked to school, and late ate his lunch. 這是錯的..

所以..意思是..這題目的C答案只是相對其餘四個答案最好的最合理的..但其實它是錯誤的? 還是曼哈頓中文精簡版解釋過於絕對??求解釋...本人語法超差T T

miki_042

還有..我看PREP08覺得有好多解釋都看不懂和看不進去...但看曼哈頓中文精簡版就覺得好清晰.學到很多..這是什麽原因T T有人跟我一樣麼?..PREP08應該是很好的複習資料吧?

448258130

呵呵，你果然看的很不仔细。这个题号是prep08-194，考点4已经将逗号解释的很清楚了。简而言之就是为了句子清晰

miki_042

448258130 发表于 2013-11-12 11:46
呵呵，你果然看的很不仔细。这个题号是prep08-194，考点4已经将逗号解释的很清楚了。简而言之就是为了句子 ...

所以意思是說...我說的and前面有逗號and后必定有主語的說法是過於絕對? 有時是可以省略???我給出的那個例句到底是對還是錯的?

448258130

miki_042 发表于 2013-11-12 17:13
所以意思是說...我說的and前面有逗號and后必定有主語的說法是過於絕對? 有時是可以省略???我給出的那個例 ...

看语义，太崇尚语法规则会被反噬

miki_042

448258130 发表于 2013-11-12 17:28
看语义，太崇尚语法规则会被反噬

好暈~~~我覺得他給的例句沒有問題..但他又說那是錯的= =

448258130

miki_042 发表于 2013-11-12 21:26
好暈~~~我覺得他給的例句沒有問題..但他又說那是錯的= =

gmac绝对不会单独只拿逗号来做考点的

miki_042

448258130 发表于 2013-11-12 21:35
gmac绝对不会单独只拿逗号来做考点的

好的..謝謝..所以意思是要聯繫各個選項做決定