OG13 Q76 求大家指教

linnnn

Q76: combining enormaous physcial strength with higher intelligence, the Neanderthals appear as equipped for facing any obstacle the environment could put in their path, but their relatively sudden disappearance during the Paleolithic era indicates that an inavility to adapt to some environmental change led to their extinction."

correct answer: (B) appear to have been equipped to face any obstacle the environment could put in their path

正確答案中使用了"appear to have been equipped",雖然根據 講解中的"appear"要用現在時和"equipped to face"已經可以看出答案要選B,但是爲什麽要用"appear to have been equipped"呢? 可以說"appear as equipped to" 呢?

求大家指教!

linnnn

没有人解答呢~~~

拧发条喵

Because Neanderthals“disappeared”，the verb describing their apparent abilities cannot be present tense, so as equipped must be changged to to have been equipped

appear as equipped 不好
√Imperfactions APPEAR AS tiny cracks（=show up as）
×He APPEARS AS confused./ The dinosaurs APPEARED AS smart.

这些资料里都有解释的…

linnnn

拧发条喵 发表于 2013-8-15 13:39
Because Neanderthals“disappeared”，the verb describing their apparent abilities cannot be present  ...

谢谢阿

那可以用'appeared'吗？

拧发条喵

linnnn 发表于 2013-8-15 17:36
谢谢阿

那可以用'appeared'吗？

不可以
后面indicates也是现在时，appear要与之平行，另表现它是现在的线索（虽然是关于历史情况）

linnnn

拧发条喵 发表于 2013-8-15 18:09
不可以
后面indicates也是现在时，appear要与之平行，另表现它是现在的线索（虽然是关于历史情况）
...

再仔细体会了一下，因为有disappeared, 所以不能用equipped。而本来应该是had been equipped, 但是是在appear to后面所以had要用原形，所以就变成了appear to have been equipped.对么？

拧发条喵

linnnn 发表于 2013-8-16 12:44
再仔细体会了一下，因为有disappeared, 所以不能用equipped。而本来应该是had been equipped, 但是是在ap ...

@@
等一下…你把我绕晕了…
为什么要用过去完成时…用现在完成时就好了呀
是因为disappeared 所以不能用现在时要用完成时
"appear as ADJ" is unidiomatic; the correct version is "appear to be ADJ", or, if someone/something was ADJ in the past, "appear to have been ADJ".

linnnn

拧发条喵 发表于 2013-8-16 14:44
@@
等一下…你把我绕晕了…
为什么要用过去完成时…用现在完成时就好了呀

但是'eqquiped'不是现在时，是过去时阿。

拧发条喵

linnnn 发表于 2013-8-16 14:51
但是'eqquiped'不是现在时，是过去时阿。

这里equipped不是过去式…是一个固定搭配
现在时：He is equipped with much experience in teaching.

linnnn

拧发条喵 发表于 2013-8-16 15:02
这里equipped不是过去式…是一个固定搭配
现在时：He is equipped with much experience in teaching. ...

所以是appear to be equipped as里面的be要换成have been？