请帮忙评估一下上Top20商科Phd的机会

boyinwind

没戏，洗洗睡吧

bestrabbit

zzmypster 发表于 2013-8-9 11:33
都消停点，回到正题来吧。楼主，饶我多说一句，从你之前的发言看，对bschool phd这个行当了解确实不多，这 ...

谢谢

bill2008

bestrabbit 发表于 2013-8-7 21:36
这个。。。各位大牛，首先，我想地球人都知道princeton和yale的b schl之类的都是joke，如果我是princeton ...

激烈反应都是因为你说这个引起的。不过我是认为反应过于激烈了（如果还是男生的话）。感觉楼主还是有风度的。个人觉得Duke的marketing那是很牛逼啊啊啊。

bennywang2usa

美国居然只拿到3.2 。。。好低啊。。。

Tripleg

lana6 发表于 2013-8-7 10:44
各位前辈，top10/20/50 的PhD是指哪些学校啊？

I attempted to set up a ranking of the top 50 PhD programs in the US based on these criteria: 1. faculty research output; 2. graduate placement; 3. overall reputation of the university; and 4. "traditional preferences" in China. Hopes this makes sense although it is highly "controversial".

TOP 10
Harvard
Upenn
Chicago
MIT
Stanford
Columbia
Berkeley
Carnegie Mellon
Yale (The Yale program is small and strong. However, I put it here mainly on criteria 3. and 4.)
Northwestern

TOP 30
Southern California
Michigan –Ann Arbor
UIUC
Cornell
Penn State
Michigan State
Texas –Austin
Maryland-College Park
North Carolina-Chapel Hill
UCLA
Ohio State
Washington-St. Louis
Wisconsin-Madison
Minnesota-Twin Cities
Indiana-Bloomington
Georgia Institute of Technology
Arizona State
Florida
Washington-Seattle
Texas A&M

TOP 50
Emory (Placement record is average.)
Texas-Dallas
Pittsburg
Boston College
Boston University
Purdue
Rutgers
Georgia
Connecticut
Georgia State
Rice
Rochester
UC-Irvine
UC-Boulder
George Washington
Arizona
Houston
Baruch College
South Carolina
Iowa

TOP 60
Utah
Missouri
Miami -Florida
Temple
Oregon
Buffalo
Virginia Tech
Drexel
Washington State
Tulane

Zingales

cmu也就是marketing里面的quant能排进前10吧，剩下的专业没有一个close to top 10吧，cmu曾经很强，不过这个曾经，有点遥远，30年前了。。。

第二档里面的msu，wisc，indiana，gatech， asu，florida，都太一般了

drma

Tripleg 发表于 2013-8-24 09:39
I attempted to set up a ranking of the top 50 PhD programs in the US based on these criteria: 1. f ...

Great advice! Hope everyone else can see this, at least take a look as a ref. Thinking about making it a thread? Current rankings offered by medias all consider different criterias.

lana6

Tripleg 发表于 2013-8-24 09:39
I attempted to set up a ranking of the top 50 PhD programs in the US based on these criteria: 1. f ...

太感谢了！
这个排名划分 分专业吗？
比如Accounting也差不多这个划分，对吗？

zjq407

CMU的marketing这几年下滑比较严重。孙宝红走了之后quant那边就不太行了，这两年上market的candidates工作都找的一般，还有一个都没找到tenure track工作的；CB那边最senior的一个faculty今年去了Tilburg，剩下的都是比较junior的而且nurturing也不太好。总之这个program有点被吹捧过头了。

liuxinghuaguo

Tripleg 发表于 2013-8-24 09:39
I attempted to set up a ranking of the top 50 PhD programs in the US based on these criteria: 1. f ...

marketing的排名？